Craft breweries over-hopping every style of beer…

Posts
1,301
Likes
15,666
I had discovered Newcastle Brown Ale several years ago, and it was available in the US. Then a couple years ago I noticed that the logo and the recipe had changed to a hoppier version for the US. Very disappointing. Spotted Cow from Wisconsin requires a 45 minute drive to the border from Illinois, but is worth the trip!


Newcaste was my favorite in the 90's until it started to give me a splitting headache after drinking one bottle. I tried it again a couple of years ago with no splitting headache. I looked at the label and it said it was brewed in the Netherlands. Still tasted good though. Hefeweizen is my favorite style these days.
 
Posts
2,665
Likes
3,547
Disclosure: I'm a part-owner of a craft brewery and distillery which is guilty of some of these sins (and not so much of others). Happy to try to answer any questions about the industry.

appreciate the insight. I can see that breweries are trying to differentiate their product to attract customers, but if EVERY brewery is over-hopping what should be non-hoppy beers, how is this unique? I also don’t understand WHY overly-hoppy beers are so popular. All i taste is the bitterness and some grapefruit - pretty much all other flavors are overwhelmed. Perhaps it’s just my palate (I like sweet more than spicy),, but I can get more flavors out of a classic ale than from an over-hopped one.
 
Posts
2,665
Likes
3,547
Newcaste was my favorite in the 90's until it started to give me a splitting headache after drinking one bottle. I tried it again a couple of years ago with no splitting headache. I looked at the label and it said it was brewed in the Netherlands. Still tasted good though. Hefeweizen is my favorite style these days.

I’ve had an over-hopped Hefeweizen from a local brewery, which of course tasted like an IPA. They can ruin anything.
 
Posts
1,421
Likes
3,596
I agree with OP. Give me a Suntory Premium Malt’s or don’t give me anything.

I absolutely hate craft beer.
Edited:
 
Posts
1,144
Likes
3,111
Being in Vermont I’m spoiled by some of the best craft breweries around. Many of them have shifted away from the over hopped beers. Still plenty of amazing double ipas but a ton of good pilsners, stouts, sours, ales. Honestly the local choices spoils the hell out of us.

I have a brewery a quarter mile from my house, they don’t make the worlds best beers but they’re fantastic, pre-Covid we’d go a few times a month, pick up food and eat it there. Their Oktoberfest parties were great and they’d have a
keg of Weihenstephan Festbier.

It was the last place we went before Covid, 5 days before lockdown, and the first place we went when things opened back up.

Well, I’m thirsty now.
 
Posts
942
Likes
15,374
IPAs bore me, I like a variety of different brews. I’ve really enjoyed the multitude of new sour ales the past few summers from local breweries.
 
Posts
9,496
Likes
52,094
Draft Yuengling lager. These guys know how to brew beer and they’ve been doing it continuously since 1829.
 
Posts
5,636
Likes
5,800
Draft Yuengling lager. These guys know how to brew beer and they’ve been doing it continuously since 1829.
Haven't had the pleasure but what I've had in bottles has been pretty nice. They don't ship that to Milwaukee.
 
Posts
1,144
Likes
3,111
Back when I was in high school and college yuengling was a special treat, only to be had if a friend traveled the Pennsylvania and was able to bring some back. They have a much wider distribution today.
 
Posts
1,144
Likes
3,111
Maybe my favorite brewery that I haven’t gotten to visit yet is Firestone Walker, I want to visit their barrel works during one of their events.
 
Posts
9,496
Likes
52,094
Back when I was in high school and college yuengling was a special treat, only to be had if a friend traveled the Pennsylvania and was able to bring some back. They have a much wider distribution today.
Yes, still the same great brew though. It’s the oldest independent brewery in the US, still family owned and operated.
 
Posts
1,144
Likes
3,111
I’ll still grab one now and then but it’s hard not to buy the local options we have. I’m probably due for one though, I’ll have to grab some next time I’m in need.
 
Posts
415
Likes
1,088
Enjoy seeing a Yuengling shout out here. As a born and bred Philly kid, still tickles me that to this day the words lager and Yuengling are synonymous in every bar in PA.
 
Posts
86
Likes
44
Anyone else hate the way craft breweries are destroying perfectly good beer styles by adding so many hops they taste no different than an IPA? I’m talking brown ales, red ales, amber ales, bocks, lagers, etc. These beer recipes are hundreds of years old and there’s a reason for it - they’ve always had a perfect balance of hops and malt to give the perfect taste profile. Adding more of either doesn’t make it better - kinda like adding more salt to something because a little makes it taste great.

Just tried an Octoberfest Marzen from a local craft brewery. Lots of advertisements on social media talking about how they did it in the traditional way - brewed in March, aged through the summer, then released on Sept. 1. I was hoping for the best, even though all their other beers are over-hopped. Shouldn’t have bothered - tasted like an IPA with just a little more malt thrown in in deference to the Marzen recipe.

luckily I bought a 6-pack of Sam Adams Octoberfest at the same time. At least they follow the tradional recipe and it tastes like a Marzen.

and don’t get me started on craft whiskey distillers that sell a 2-year-old single “small barrel” bourbon for 2 to 3 times the price of a bottle of Wild Turkey 101. Yeah, Wild Turkey isn’t “craft”, it uses a blend of barrels, but they’ve used the same recipe for nearly 100 years and those barrels are aged in Kentucky for 6-8 years and even longer.

rant over

😀

Great Lakes Oktoberfest - all you need to know. Except for Ayinger that is. And Pauliner.
 
Posts
806
Likes
2,108
Hate to admit it, but lately I’ve been favoring Coors tallboys. And Scotch, of course.
 
Posts
942
Likes
15,374
I had a keg of Yuengling at my wedding, good times! Here in Maryland we also have the new guinness brewery…
 
Posts
1,689
Likes
5,125
It's funny but I thought I'd been going crazy with this that so many beers now taste too hoppy. I've been drinking ale for best part of thirty years and is only the past year or so I've come to really dislike the overpowering hoppy aftertaste so many beers leave you with.

I've found myself experimenting with new brews less and less and going back to some old favourite as the safer bets.

Glad to read I'm not the only one feeling this way.
 
Posts
3,751
Likes
10,243
@Donn Chambers Shinerbock is my go to as well. Not only do I think that they make an excellent bock (lager) I enjoy several of their seasonal brews. I think their seasonal stuff is the only thing they tinker with recipes on, I don't think they ever mess around with the regular bock.
 
Posts
778
Likes
718
Big fan of double IPA’s and best of all Treehouse opened up here on Cape Cod. They produce some of the best beer ( not just DIPA’s ) anywhere. In a few weeks I’ll be drinking their stouts which are also highly regarded.
Treehouse is always experimenting with different hop combinations and producing interesting new beers filled with juiciness