Automatic not automatic-ing

Posts
1,581
Likes
2,307
I’ll start by saying: I’m sending this watch in for service. This isn’t one of those threads where the OP is in denial or asking permission not to.

This is my 2016 Rio Seamaster, so an 8 year old watch that’s due. And it was a little rough when I bought it on eBay—a refinish will do it some good. Was always planning to send it in.

My question: I’ve noticed that the watch doesn’t seem to recharge with typical wear. I wind it fully (70 good turns) and wear it for two days—and I’m pretty active during those days—and then the watch stops in the middle of the night. This doesn’t happen with any of my other automatics. …What’s up with that?

It seems to have its full power reserve. And I know the rotor isn’t stuck because I can hear it moving around when I rotate the watch. So I’m guessing the issue is that rotor is somehow no longer engaged with the winding mechanism—? Does that seem right?

SWATCH will sort it—I’m just curious.

Obligatory wrist shot.
 
Posts
20,038
Likes
46,650
If there is excessive friction in the autowinding mechanism, it may not be working efficiently.
 
Posts
1,581
Likes
2,307
That makes sense.

It’s probably totally unrelated, but one thing I didn’t mention: this watch has the noisiest rotor I’ve ever encountered.
 
Posts
20,038
Likes
46,650
If it has always been noisy, it's probably unrelated. But if it became more noisy over time, I suppose that could indicate a problem.
 
Posts
1,581
Likes
2,307
Just dropped it off at AD. Quoted 3 to 4 months.

No white speedies to be seen.
 
Posts
2,430
Likes
3,312
That makes sense.

It’s probably totally unrelated, but one thing I didn’t mention: this watch has the noisiest rotor I’ve ever encountered.

That is likely an indication of the problem -- I had the standard version of that Seamaster and the rotor made no noise that I could discern.
 
Posts
373
Likes
445
Gorgeous and underrated SMP. Should be running like a champ for many years after service.
 
Posts
121
Likes
207
ETA 2892 is quite well know for that kind of problems after a few years. Hope you specified the problem or else they can miss it and give back the watch as it. Happened to me on a Breitling.
 
Posts
1,581
Likes
2,307
I did specify—but I’m confident they’d have fixed it regardless, as (in my experience) SWATCH does a complete disassembly and overhaul. I suspect I may get that noisy rotor back in the replaced parts baggie.
 
Posts
121
Likes
207
Probably. Breitling take it back for free anyway. I have the same watch (normal blue one) and a lots of 2892 and for sure, it's not supposed to that noisy.
 
Posts
243
Likes
352
It’s possible the reversing wheels in the automatic winding works may have an issue. Regardless, please be sure to post back and let us know. Good luck.
 
Posts
27,308
Likes
69,636
I did specify—but I’m confident they’d have fixed it regardless, as (in my experience) SWATCH does a complete disassembly and overhaul. I suspect I may get that noisy rotor back in the replaced parts baggie.

They will fix it. If the rotor is noisy, it could be a worn bearing. This will cause the automatic winding to be less efficient. Different than the typical issues with the 2892...
 
Posts
4
Likes
1
Just dropped it off at AD. Quoted 3 to 4 months.

No white speedies to be seen.

wow, I never knew AD's took that long to service. Good to know.
 
Posts
2,430
Likes
3,312
wow, I never knew AD's took that long to service. Good to know.

It was probably shipped to an Omega service center, so you have to count that into the time. But independent watchmakers also tend to have lots of business and likely won’t get it back in a short time frame. For instance, I dropped my Speedmaster off at my local watchmaker at the end of December, knowing that there were quite a few watches already in the queue — including two other Speedmasters dropped off that day. Got a call about three weeks later with the quote for the overhaul and if I wanted to proceed — my watchmaker always wants to do an initial inspection before quoting a price to see if any additional parts are required. I gave approval but it wasn’t done until early March — most likely because he had to wait for parts to arrive.
 
Posts
1,581
Likes
2,307
wow, I never knew AD's took that long to service. Good to know.

AD was submitting to Omega/Swatch for me—not an in-house service.