I looked back at the original post, and the watch is in nice condition, but it clearly was never NOS. There was an obvious small scratch on the dial by the 3 o'clock marker and many fine scratches on the case, etc. Yes, it's in great condition for a watch of its age, and the minor flaws you have found don't really change that fact.
More to the point ... now that I know what watch we are talking about, this seems like much ado about nothing. NOS condition only matters for really desirable investment pieces that you plan to put in a safe and save for the future. You don't wear NOS watches. A gold-plated Cortebert is just not in this category. So maybe a mint gold-plated Cortebert is worth $150 and yours is worth $125, it's just not worth getting worked up about. The crime is that you paid $1k, regardless of condition.
Now I understand why the seller doesn't really care if he gets the watch back. The upside isn't very high for him, and he'd rather take his chances on getting your $1k.
Click to expand...