I tend to think that I am somewhat of a tire connoisseur. For $900 cash + an 8oz bottle of hand sanitizer, these wheels and tires didn't cost me much at all. The Subaru dealer wants $3400 for a set of the wheels alone. So the tires were like free and the wheels were 1/4 price.
The Continental Extreme Contact DSW have been great tires for several of our cars over the past many years (2005 Impreza, 2006 RAV4, 2008 Infiniti G35x, 2017 WRX). I was going to get Michelin Premier A/S like on our Forester XT, but they didn't make it in the correct size for my WRX. As far as I can tell, the Continental perform just as well, but with better wear although worse noise.
I've had Blizzak on my previous 2004 STi and they wore out so fast but worked great, so I also used them on the Forester XT when it was my primary car. The General Arctic Altimax were good on snow and lasted long, but sucked on icy roads vs the Blizzak. A good compromise snow tire (balanced performance on dry, wet, snow, ice) has been the Yokahama Ice Guard, which seems to rank a close 3rd in tests vs the Blizzak and X-ice; but they have been a lot noisier than Blizzak or X-ice. We had the Ice Guard on our Subaru Tribeca, WRX, Forester XT, and Impreza Sport. But, as of this winter we now we have the X-ice on my WRX, the Forester XT my son drives, and the Grand Cherokee that my daughter drives. I sold the Yokahama from the WRX in January when I got the X-ice, but we kept a spare set for the Forester on 17" rims while the X-ice for Forester have to go on the same rims as the summer tires.
For performance, the Dunlop SuperSport that came with the WRX were very sticky and lasted, but were quite noisy. When the shop ripped the bead on two of them trying to remove them after 3 summers, I couldn't replace just one, and had 2 more years left in them, so the shop GAVE me new tires. I picked Michelin Pilot Sport 4s to replace them, but I had to pay the price difference between the Dunlop and Michelin (like $40/tire I think).
So, when it's all over I'll have the Pilot Sport 4s on the new gold BBS rims, the Continental all-seasons will stay on the refurbished painted gold BBS rims to use in April/May and October each year, and the X-ice will stay on the stock black OEM wheels for use in Nov-March.
View attachment 978620
The new rims have barely used Champiro WinterPro HP on them, but as a medium grade winter tire I'd probably use them as an all-season in spring and fall after I wear out the Continentals.
Click to expand...