Advice about service centre

Posts
230
Likes
140
Hi. I'm pretty pissed off. I bought my grail watch and it came to me in working condition however started playing up after not long so I took it to be looked at. The service centre quoted me for a service with new balance as the old one was buckled, change of crystal and main spring. I accepted the rather high quote as the balance was really difficult to acquire and I knew this as looked into different people for the job.
8 weeks later I get the phone call saying it's done and I go and pick it up, pay and get given the watch. Now upon immediate inspection I had noticed the hands had been changed and were different. I quizzed them on it and the brought down the technician who explained the original handset weren't correct as they didnt fit the pinion. (to which I thought sounded strange as nearly every photo I had of that reference had the leaf handset that was with the watch. I'm not saying he was lying but it sounded strange. I said if he was going to put a new handset in and make alterations to the piece he should have asked me first. He tried to belittle me and give me alternatum saying I can either take the work that he has done with the different handset (which I didnt like) or he would put the piece back together with the buckled balance not working and I go away to find someone "better" to do the job.
Anyway I thought this was a bit peculiar. Ok it does sound as if it could be the case as the handset might have been swiped out on previous work and modified to fit the pinion but it didnt smell right so I asked if he still has the leaf hands and why they weren't included in the package with the old crystal (which was included).
So he goes upstairs and brings down a box which he had kept them in and starts showing me a broken wheel which needed replacing and the bad balance and then the second hand...And THEN one of the hands which had snapped...and there it is I'm now thinking this guy has snapped the old hands getting them off and swopped them for different hands thinking I might not notice. I'm screwing.
Anyway I got a refund of the work undertaken and asked him to fix the hand if possible as I'm sure it's the original one.
It wasn't a cheap piece and very rare...causing some of the issues with supplies but don't you think he they should have spoken to me about the work before making these decisions? They must have broke the hands and then sourced different hands to try and cover the breakage.
Give me some advice please as I'm still screwing over this.
 
Posts
24,257
Likes
54,015
What type of "service center" are you referring to. This does not sound like an official Omega service center operation. What is the watch? Can you show photos?
 
Posts
230
Likes
140
What type of "service center" are you referring to. This does not sound like an official Omega service center operation. What is the watch? Can you show photos?

It's a professional service centre in Essex UK. They are nothing to do with Omega and the watch is a vintage Longines from 1942. I trusted them because they have worked on my watches before and I've never had a problem until now.
I didn't take photos of the work they did as I was so cross...in hindsight I should have done but I just wanted them to fix what they had done.
 
Posts
24,257
Likes
54,015
I see, so it's an independent watch repair shop? It's unfortunate when things like this happen, and obviously they should have been honest and upfront with you. It's good that they refunded your payment. I would not use them again. It would certainly be reasonable for you to ask them to find the correct hands for you. No harm in trying.
 
Posts
230
Likes
140
I see, so it's an independent watch repair shop? It's unfortunate when things like this happen, and obviously they should have been honest and upfront with you. It's good that they refunded your payment. I would not use them again. It would certainly be reasonable for you to ask them to find the correct hands for you. No harm in trying.

I'm screwing because I asked an ex Longines service guy to once find these hands and he said it would be impossible. I dont know what to do seriously. They are adamant the handset isnt correct to try and uphold their story that the swop of hands was the best course of action. Maybe I should quiz them for measurements of the old hands because i know what size they should be to fit the pinion. I could even ask for them to measure them to see if they're lying. This really sucks
 
Posts
24,257
Likes
54,015
Perhaps you can post photos of the watch and the hands and add Longines to the title. Or maybe start a new thread on the Longines forum specifically about the watch and the hands. With photos and details. There are quite a few Longines expert on OF. Otherwise, I'm not sure how we can help.
 
Posts
230
Likes
140
Perhaps you can post photos of the watch and the hands and add Longines to the title. Or maybe start a new thread on the Longines forum specifically about the watch and the hands. With photos and details. There are quite a few Longines expert on OF. Otherwise, I'm not sure how we can help.

Longines 4915
 
Posts
24,257
Likes
54,015
These are the new hands, or the old hands?
 
Posts
16,863
Likes
47,901
You do realise old hands can be quiet fragile. Doesn’t excuse not telling you but sometimes things break
 
Posts
24,257
Likes
54,015
I'm thinking that the hands in that photo look quite good to me. If those are the ones that were installed, they may be correct.
 
Posts
230
Likes
140
You do realise old hands can be quiet fragile. Doesn’t excuse not telling you but sometimes things break
Yeah I can imagine, it's just they included the old crystal from the service and said nothing about the hand set swop hoping I wouldn't notice I'm sure. I'm really not enamoured with the new hands...the old leaf ones in the photo are lovely and make the watch.

Just wish they had been upfront with me about it and not try and play me off
 
Posts
230
Likes
140
Thing is also I've had this watch before with a redial and it had the same hands so that leans towards it being correct the way it was.

I sent the refinished dial back in exchange because I couldn't live with the unoriginality...hence not having the original hands on this one would bug me.

in hindsight I should have kept the one with the refinished dial and swopped the hands over if I knew this was gonna happen.
 
Posts
16,863
Likes
47,901
old hands

Can we see the new hands…..
 
Posts
24,257
Likes
54,015
I agree that the old hands look totally appropriate for the reference. I'd also be interested in seeing the new hands.
 
Posts
230
Likes
140
Can we see the new hands…..
I didnt take a picture as I was too angry. They were metallic blue and sourced from an original 12.68 movement similar reference but didnt look right to me.
 
Posts
16,863
Likes
47,901
I didnt take a picture as I was too angry. They were metallic blue and sourced from an original 12.68 movement similar reference but didnt look right to me.

Angry, could tell by your first post here. 😁

I love it when someone is angry as paragraphs go out the window 😉

😁😁
 
Posts
230
Likes
140
Angry, could tell by your first post here. 😁

I love it when someone is angry as paragraphs go out the window 😉

😁😁

Oh that's just my poor punctuation.