33mm on an 8 inch wrist. Too small?

Posts
13,307
Likes
18,417
People had 8” wrists in the 1930’s too.

HamiltonCatalog1935_Page_12.jpg

This is a page from the 1935 Hamilton catalog. The three watches on top right and far left are 28mm diameter. They are really small.

But as you can see, men of the time had no problem with them. That trend continued until after WWII.
gatorcpa
 
Posts
1,430
Likes
2,957
Nice looking watch, and, many of the above posts have offered great thoughts. I agree, get a larger strap like the bund. You must remember when wristwatches were initially worn most were converted pocket watches... so big. Then much smaller sizes became popular, until they weren't. It's all about fashion... in the 1930s a man with an 8 inch wrist wouldn't have thought twice about wearing a 30mm or smaller watch, that was the norm. Today, big watches are the fad, most everybody wants a BIG wristwatch, hell, the case sizes today range from 36mm to 54mm and Panerai even put out a whopping 60mm case, the Egiziano Pam 341 a reproduction of the Egyptian navy watch. It's all what YOU thinks looks good, but, since, you asked, I don't think it looks too small.

Now doesn't the Pam 341 look too big on this guy's wrist?
 
Posts
8,617
Likes
71,222
Nice looking watch, and, many of the above posts have offered great thoughts. I agree, get a larger strap like the bund. You must remember when wristwatches were initially worn most were converted pocket watches... so big. Then much smaller sizes became popular, until they weren't. It's all about fashion... in the 1930s a man with an 8 inch wrist wouldn't have thought twice about wearing a 30mm or smaller watch, that was the norm. Today, big watches are the fad, most everybody wants a BIG wristwatch, hell, the case sizes today range from 36mm to 54mm and Panerai even put out a whopping 60mm case, the Egiziano Pam 341 a reproduction of the Egyptian navy watch. It's all what YOU thinks looks good, but, since, you asked, I don't think it looks too small.

Now doesn't the Pam 341 look too big on this guy's wrist?
I have bigger and heavier watches I rarely if ever wear. My 34/35mm watches are virtually weightless and discreet (as in both comfortable and unostentatious) although I am prepared to forgo a multitude of subdials and bezels with numbers on.
 
Posts
1,106
Likes
1,654
I'd much rather wear a 30mm vintage watch than a 40mm new watch.
 
Posts
362
Likes
560
Wear what makes you happy. It’s about your enjoyment not what ‘we’ think. However, it looks good to me!
 
Posts
773
Likes
1,373
Here's my 33mm watch. I wear it with the 12mm strap, like it's supposed to be worn. If it was good enough for military officers back in WW I, then I'm cool with it.

Edited:
 
Posts
16,307
Likes
44,994
Here's my 33mm watch. I wear it with the 12mm strap, like it's supposed to be worn. If it was good enough for military officers back in WW I, then I'm cool with it.

The slender strap really makes the head appear larger. One would think a chunkier strap would bulk up the watch, but it's actually the opposite effect.
Lovely wire lug- like my watchmaker told me in one breath when handing back a Longines trench watch to me "beautiful watch don't get this thing anywhere near water"
 
Posts
339
Likes
2,313
Here's my 33mm watch. I wear it with the 12mm strap, like it's supposed to be worn. If it was good enough for military officers back in WW I, then I'm cool with it.

Hi. I’m looking at buying a similar Smith Trench watch. Any idea what year yours is please? Thanks
 
Posts
453
Likes
679
Lug to lug is 42mm. Good call on the bund, I’m liking it a lot

Nice combination of leather and canvas, could you tell me the source !?

I´ll promise i´ll post some pictures of my elgin after i received it 😀

Teaser:




I ordered a military bracelet from the us (i live in germany) just to find out that it´s missing a hole, they are stichet, so the bracelet won´t fit ::facepalm1::
 
Posts
907
Likes
2,312
Nice combination of leather and canvas, could you tell me the source !?

I´ll promise i´ll post some pictures of my elgin after i received it 😀

Teaser:




I ordered a military bracelet from the us (i live in germany) just to find out that it´s missing a hole, they are stichet, so the bracelet won´t fit ::facepalm1::
Can’t help you I’m afraid, I made it myself from two straps I already had.
 
Posts
15,048
Likes
24,057
If you are Uncle Henry, no. If you are a member here, yes it is too small. 😁
 
Posts
453
Likes
679
Can’t help you I’m afraid, I made it myself from two straps I already had.

that's an idea, this will be my new challenge 😀
 
Posts
453
Likes
679
If you are Uncle Henry, no. If you are a member here, yes it is too small. 😁

I don't know who uncle henry is but uncle wuza has a wrist measurement of 185mm / ~7.30 inches.

I would say healthy average arm 😀
 
Posts
773
Likes
1,373
Hi. I’m looking at buying a similar Smith Trench watch. Any idea what year yours is please? Thanks

Absolutely. Per the caseback, London assayed, George Stockwell imported, and 1915 hallmark.

And serviced in 1928. 😉


 
Posts
339
Likes
2,313
Absolutely. Per the caseback, London assayed, George Stockwell imported, and 1915 hallmark.

And serviced in 1928. 😉


Thanks. One I’ve good for hasn’t got as good lume on hands as yours and surprisingly is hallmarked 1927