1967/68 Speedmaster - BBC Antiques Roadshow

Posts
1,396
Likes
2,705
So, “the bastards cheat...” you say.
Have you ever been to a UK filming of Antiques Roadshow?

Folks queue up in their thousands with bags full of multiple items.
Some folks pre-arrange a pick up of large pieces of furniture but 99.9% of the things we see on TV arrive on the day, without any forewarning.
The public is screened into sectors and you join another queue to see the allotted expert (who are all experienced dealers).

There are ‘spotters’ looking out for interesting items to show on TV and of course there is always a time-lag giving an opportunity for the experts to consult with their colleagues (which they often refer to )
The expert in question is more at home with centuries-old English grandfather clocks and French carriage clocks than modern watches, so you could forgive him if he did indeed need to ‘phone a friend’ occasionally.

So, yes, experts on a TV entertainment show, who have a broad knowledge of their sector but are presented with a infinitesimal range of things to look at and value and may need assistance from time to time.
Cheating bastards, I think not.

You're right they do defer or spend a bit of time doing some research before going 'on camera'. A good example was the lady with the medals on last nights program, the expert openly admitted that he had done some research on the recipients of the medals beforehand.

Based on last nights bought for a fiver I am going to have to start visiting boot fairs and junkyard sales 😁
 
Posts
44
Likes
47
Antiques roadshow is a great show, but much of it is a 'show' - they'll pick out the best items and have them pre-appraised beforehand...
 
Posts
1,296
Likes
5,991
Based on last nights bought for a fiver I am going to have to start visiting boot fairs and junkyard sales 😁

The problem with this approach, is you need to spend all your time rootling about through toot at antiques fairs 😁
It pays us all to keep an eye out though, in case you see something in passing. My favourite story is the one about the A386 and the estate sale...
https://omegaforums.net/threads/the-story-of-my-a386-el-primero-find.69297/
 
Posts
1,396
Likes
2,705
Antiques roadshow is a great show, but much of it is a 'show' - they'll pick out the best items and have them pre-appraised beforehand...

I don't doubt that, otherwise you would have a TV show which comprised of 000's of bits of tat and no real show, however I always liked the reaction of Mr or Mrs know it all when the item they are 110% sure is a rare piece because 'my aunt's husbands brothers cousin told us so' is revealed to be a modern replica or put another way a fake, don't get that as much on the show nowadays.
 
Posts
12
Likes
4
I think the whole thing was a put up job, the owner claims to have no knowledge of the significance of the Omega Speedmaster ? yeah rock on . Even a basic internet check would have highlighted its importance and value.

Paying £ 5 for it at a car boot sale - My backside - IMHO a total sham. Great TV but totally false.
 
Posts
1,396
Likes
2,705
I think the whole thing was a put up job, the owner claims to have no knowledge of the significance of the Omega Speedmaster ? yeah rock on . Even a basic internet check would have highlighted its importance and value.

Paying £ 5 for it at a car boot sale - My backside - IMHO a total sham. Great TV but totally false.

Not so sure I agree, if the story was put up by the BBC then they found a good actor, much better than some of the stars in their normal productions. I thought the guys expressions were genuine, especially when he was offered £500 for the watch and was happy to accept. He also looked shocked when the £5k value was given, I watched this program for many years and faking a shocked face is very hard to do especially if you know how much the article is worth, the vast majority fail at this point, he didn't.

Irrespective of whether it was a set-up or genuine I enjoyed the piece, and getting any watch as a subject on prime time TV is an achievement.
 
Posts
603
Likes
2,567
https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/roadshow/s.../appraisals/1963-rolex-gmt-master--201902A10/ H

Here's an appraisal of a 1675 GMT with a replaced bezel and dial from this week's episode. The dealer walked the woman through it and appraised correctly for the 2019 market. I doubt you can have people like her faking their reactions. I'm sure some owners know an estimate of their item's worth before bringing it, like the guy with the Daytona, but I don't think every appraisal is a set up where the owner knows the outcome ahead of time, they just have a general inclination since they were asked to be part of a recorded appraisal.
 
Posts
21,708
Likes
49,237
I think that the appraisers have some time to do research, which is totally appropriate, but I don't think that the owners are prepped. I have seen owners get emotional on numerous occasions (generally about the value of an heirloom), and their reactions are almost always entirely credible to me.
 
Posts
1,396
Likes
2,705
I think that the appraisers have some time to do research, which is totally appropriate, but I don't think that the owners are prepped. I have seen owners get emotional on numerous occasions (generally about the value of an heirloom), and their reactions are almost always entirely credible to me.

+1