For me option #3 is the only interesting one. It looks honest and well preserved to me. I like the dial/the tritium dots in very good condition.
Option #1 is second choice to me, as the dial is not that nice, it has too many service parts (hands, crown) and last but not least has been refinished.
Option #2: Looking at the case, this would be no option for me.
BTW: The correct bracelet / end piece combination for this watch ref. is 1170 / 653.
I agree the ebay watch was made for sale. It even had custom made end piece replacements...
Click to expand...