It's really interesting and reminds me a lot of the stories told about Jaguar ownership, i.e., "this is a car you buy with your heart, and not with your head", and of course, "you buy this one for the way it makes you feel". I imagine being an Alfisti is quite close to this experience.
With Jaguar, part of their downfall was that they went from a manufacturer with a small range of cars to a larger range of cars. Between 1968 and 1999, they basically only made luxury sedans (the XJ in all versions) and grand tourers (first the XJ-S / XJS, then the XK8). After that, they diluted the brand with new cars they basically hadn't been building before, except maybe in the 1960s, when their range was at it's most muddled and chaotic. ... Okay, the point I'm trying to get to is that maybe it's better to only have a few models that play to the strength of a brand, in this case, Alfa Romeo. A wide range may not be the best idea, I think ;-)
I’ve had many Alfas and Jaguars over the years, in both cases I found their core reliability to be fine.
Core reliability is the extent that the car will actually start and run, performing is core function as a car, it doesn’t include non essential features such as the ciggy lighter, window winders, powered seat adjusters etc.
In both manufacturers case, I found the cars as far as the engines, drive trains, suspension etc. very good mechanically, in fact superb, they were however let down electrically with the quality of the components supplied to them, and in some of the detail engineering, things like door handle and window winding mechanisms, on the alfas could drive you to distraction if you let them.
On the Jags it was mainly electrical issues that were less than par. Some of that Lucas stuff was truly horrible!
Basically the cars I could rely on to get me where I wanted to go……… just not with all the auxiliary equipment still working when I got there.
Now before anyone starts sing the praises of various Teutonic marques, let me remind you of the VW bettle, a bloody awful thing, noisey uncomfortable murderous handling, ugly as a hatful of arseholes, but reliable…..you could always rely on the 6 volt electrics to let you down, leaving you stranded on a cold wet night. Even if the thing did start the headlights were so dim that you wished it hadn’t started.
Even Mercedes Benz’s cars from the era of being built regardless of cost, had design faults which could cause reliability issues.
However desirable some of it may be, the stuff they make now has many baked in problems.
And don’t get me started on the Jap crap