- Posts
- 7,773
- Likes
- 27,028
Tony C.
··Ωf Jury memberWell worth a read (full thread linked below)...
https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1753906606738125119.html
https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1753906606738125119.html
Ultrasonic Humidifiers with Tap Water : an interesting warning
- Posts
- 28,059
- Likes
- 71,647
Archer
··Omega Qualified WatchmakerMy wife bought some of these units last winter, and they left white residue all around them - it was the minerals in the water. Stopped using them...
- Posts
- 21,768
- Likes
- 49,391
Dan S
·Unless distilled water is used, it's inevitable that solids will precipitate when the ultrasound-generated water droplets evaporate. Other types of humidifier, that generate water vapor instead of droplets, will generally be better in this regard. Of course, that leads to scaling of the heating element, but I haven't found that to be a problem in practice, they still function adequately for many years.
- Posts
- 28,059
- Likes
- 71,647
Archer
··Omega Qualified WatchmakerUnless distilled water is used, it's inevitable that solids will precipitate when the ultrasound-generated water droplets evaporate. Other types of humidifier, that generate water vapor instead of droplets, will generally be better in this regard. Of course, that leads to scaling of the heating element, but I haven't found that to be a problem in practice, they still function adequately for many years.
We have a humidifier unit on our main HVAC system, and as you say the mesh gets scaly (we clean it every year to remove that) but we just have city water going to that and there's no issue. I was surprised when we started seeing all this white particulate all over the place when we used these small units...
- Posts
- 1,047
- Likes
- 6,245
RI Omega Fan
·I was scared there for a minute, but from the article (italics mine):
“It is important to note that PM generation happens with ultrasonic humidifiers but you can use tap water with evaporative, wick-based humidifiers which does not break up the water molecules in the same way.”
Literally everyone I know who uses a humidifier, either for their bodies, furniture, or guitars, use the evaporative wicking filter type. Maybe we’re all just low-tech.
Please set me straight if I misread or misunderstood the article.
“It is important to note that PM generation happens with ultrasonic humidifiers but you can use tap water with evaporative, wick-based humidifiers which does not break up the water molecules in the same way.”
Literally everyone I know who uses a humidifier, either for their bodies, furniture, or guitars, use the evaporative wicking filter type. Maybe we’re all just low-tech.
Please set me straight if I misread or misunderstood the article.
- Posts
- 7,773
- Likes
- 27,028
Tony C.
··Ωf Jury memberPlease set me straight if I misread or misunderstood the article
You read correctly, but presumably many ultrasonic humidifiers have been sold, and are in use. [Which a quick glance at the Amazon numbers would seem to confirm.]
- Posts
- 21,768
- Likes
- 49,391
Dan S
·We have a humidifier unit on our main HVAC system, and as you say the mesh gets scaly (we clean it every year to remove that) but we just have city water going to that and there's no issue. I was surprised when we started seeing all this white particulate all over the place when we used these small units...
As you probably know, some small portable units also use evaporation.
- Posts
- 21,768
- Likes
- 49,391
- Posts
- 7,773
- Likes
- 27,028
Tony C.
··Ωf Jury memberI recall decades ago having used rolled up newspapers in a big bowl of tap water...
Cheap, effective and beautiful! 😁
Cheap, effective and beautiful! 😁
- Posts
- 3,690
- Likes
- 6,264
Vercingetorix
··Spam RiskBreathe those particles or swallow them, either way your dead in the end.
- Posts
- 21,768
- Likes
- 49,391
Dan S
·Breathe those particles or swallow them, either way your dead in the end.
- Posts
- 727
- Likes
- 2,698
rendo
·My furnace started short-cycling a couple years ago. I replaced the filter as the first, easy troubleshooting step. That fixed it, but the issue came back after a couple weeks. Called a technician, who blamed it on using a very restrictive (MPR 2200) filter. It made no sense to me, but his diagnosis was at least related to the main issue. I compared a 2-week old filter to a new one, and realized how much more white it looked. The culprit was what you shared above.
I don’t have a reason to use a humidifier all the time anymore, but when I do, I fill it with the water from my reverse osmosis tank and don’t have to deal with the white dust that goes all over.
I don’t have a reason to use a humidifier all the time anymore, but when I do, I fill it with the water from my reverse osmosis tank and don’t have to deal with the white dust that goes all over.
- Posts
- 21,768
- Likes
- 49,391
Dan S
·My furnace started short-cycling a couple years ago. I replaced the filter as the first, easy troubleshooting step. That fixed it, but the issue came back after a couple weeks. Called a technician, who blamed it on using a very restrictive (MPR 2200) filter. It made no sense to me, but his diagnosis was at least related to the main issue. I compared a 2-week old filter to a new one, and realized how much more white it looked. The culprit was what you shared above.
I don’t have a reason to use a humidifier all the time anymore, but when I do, I fill it with the water from my reverse osmosis tank and don’t have to deal with the white dust that goes all over.
- Posts
- 727
- Likes
- 2,698
rendo
·Thanks, Dan. I already have a bypass humidifier on my furnace, but for a while, it was not enough for my wife. Luckily she changed her mind at some point.
- Posts
- 773
- Likes
- 6,692
Zman4eva
·Thanks for the PSA. I had to check since we started turning on our humidifiers. All of ours were evaporative so I guess we're good?
Better break out the air quality monitor just to make sure.
Better break out the air quality monitor just to make sure.
