Community Stories

Thoughts on this Rolex 5508 please??

Castle4444
Posts
582
Likes
815
A friend of mine has been offered this Rolex 5508, interested to hear any thoughts on it, these are the only pics I have at the moment I’m afraid. I dare say if he passes and you guys don’t rip it to bits too much I may attempt it myself.
Thanks in advance. :0)
A7E3A39D-8664-463A-BD3F-5FDF8B4A3462.png 2588C928-F179-459E-9C83-D59608D96276.png BEA1A279-F0AB-4931-8C44-E1D174502ADC.png
 
Canuck
Posts
14,310
Likes
41,227
With the “rivet” bracelet (assuming it is original to the watch), the watch could be about 60 years old, or older. Rolex watches don’t last forever, especially since parts for some of the older calibers are scarce, and even Rolex refuses to service some older ones. I think it would be a mistake to buy this watch without having someone evaluate the movement.
 
Castle4444
Posts
582
Likes
815
Can’t speak for my friend but me personally I would want to see a lot more pictures and here other members thoughts before I’d pull the trigger
 
Castle4444
Posts
582
Likes
815
Few more pics. The owner said it’s been serviced 2 times by Rolex in 63 and 74, it has a service dial and hands.
6DC1FCE9-C168-47D1-813A-891CA55F76A3.png D9761FA4-9BA6-44B7-8594-B2D46BF63A0B.png D2424C26-8ABF-43B7-A142-D04F27984ED8.png AB5011BA-5E7A-4825-ACE2-6D0522862093.png ADF26279-1EB3-4ABE-A7D2-34D73EBE8169.png 4055BF91-02A0-4B87-866C-91A3CEC8BC33.png 665019F0-F319-4124-935D-DF27E5D6EB5E.jpeg
 
Castle4444
Posts
582
Likes
815
Canuck Canuck
With the “rivet” bracelet (assuming it is original to the watch), the watch could be about 60 years old, or older. Rolex watches don’t last forever, especially since parts for some of the older calibers are scarce, and even Rolex refuses to service some older ones. I think it would be a mistake to buy this watch without having someone evaluate the movement.
Think it’s the slightly later movement early 60’s not a 58 ???
 
Canuck
Posts
14,310
Likes
41,227
Take note of the 111.1958 stamped inside the case back! I estimated 60 years old or perhaps a bit older. Can’t come much closer’n that for an estimate. The movement is a caliber 1530 which is encouraging. The rather haphazard scrawl of the two repair numbers inside the case back doesn’t really look like repair numbers that might have been placed there by a Rolex tech.
 
Nobel Prize
Posts
6,832
Likes
13,793
Service dial and hands but they’re good examples so not a deal breaker. Heavily polished case though, looses a little of character
 
calalum
Posts
1,515
Likes
7,800
Depends if you are willing to live with the service dial and hands and whatever other issues.
 
Castle4444
Posts
582
Likes
815
Thanks for all the info. He’s looking for £11500 on a leather strap or £12750 on the bracelet which has been refurbished by Michael Young. I think it’s all it’s money personally?
He would trade but I wouldn’t want to give up my newly acquired SM 300 2913-8 for it.
7646062C-D221-4F43-A4F5-C3F601101AAF.jpeg
 
Nobel Prize
Posts
6,832
Likes
13,793
Castle4444 Castle4444
Thanks for all the info. He’s looking for £11500 on a leather strap or £12750 on the bracelet which has been refurbished by Michael Young. I think it’s all it’s money personally?
He would trade but I wouldn’t want to give up my newly acquired SM 300 2913-8 for it.
7646062C-D221-4F43-A4F5-C3F601101AAF.jpeg
No, don’t trade. That’s a beautiful watch.

His price is not bad all things considered. Maybe 10% or 15% wiggle room there
 
onthedial
Posts
367
Likes
463
@Castle4444
My thoughts on 50s era Submariners: It's very, very difficult to find one without a service dial. Since the service dial is often quite vintage itself, a lot of collectors don't consider this issue a deal breaker. When you get into 60s & 70s era Rolex sports watches, service dials are much less tolerated.
 
calalum
Posts
1,515
Likes
7,800
Here is my 5508 with what I understand is the original dial. I would like to find a cleaner original dial but if the choice is a beaten dial that matches a 60 year old watch and a shiny replacement dial, personally I will choose the old dial. JMHO.
Submariner pair.JPG
 
Linesiders
Posts
530
Likes
2,300
calalum calalum
Here is my 5508 with what I understand is the original dial. I would like to find a cleaner original dial but if the choice is a beaten dial that matches a 60 year old watch and a shiny replacement dial, personally I will choose the old dial. JMHO.
Submariner pair.JPG

Screw the 5508 - tell me about the PCG ; )

Mine days hello

7928-EXPCG-May.jpg
 
Linesiders
Posts
530
Likes
2,300
calalum calalum
Like yours, gilt/gilt/gilt. 1961.

Such a great piece - one of my favorites ; )
 
Sign up or log in to reply...

Similar threads

O

Is this Rolex 5513 Relumed?

ohaidere Rolex Watches
southtexas
southtexas
Posts
8
Views
3K
BrandonP

Is this Rolex Oyster Perpetual Datejust real?

BrandonP Rolex Watches
Watch my Whisky
Watch my Whisky
Posts
23
Views
6K
Thommas

Thoughts on this Rolex Explorer 1016

Thommas Rolex Watches
SpeedyPhill
SpeedyPhill
Posts
42
Views
8K
lo1979

Please advice about this Rolex submariner 14060

lo1979 Rolex Watches
VinceFR
VinceFR
Posts
9
Views
6K
jove14

Have you seen this "Rolex" on the bay!

jove14 Open Discussion
p4ul
p4ul
Posts
3
Views
1K
lawler

Any red flags on this Rolex Submariner Date 16610?

lawler Rolex Watches
Fabrice M
Fabrice M
Posts
11
Views
2K