Hello,
Are you part of the SLC_Chrono group? If not you should look them up on IG. They are a group of watch enthusiasts that meet monthly. One of the guys is a watchmaker. I went to one of their GTGs when I was visiting last year. I live on San Diego and we have a sister group here.
Just in case you change your mind about restoration, I’ll offer another vote for Tanner Morehouse (TMWatchco.com). He’s done a few watches for me and is a master at restoring these style cases through laser welding and re-lapping. He can also do the movement service and crystal replacement. Your watch could look new (if you want that).
Which will probably look ~pristine, while the rest of the watch looks like it has been dragged behind a truck for about 50 miles. In general I would agree with the "leave it alone" approach, but this one is too far gone IMO. Whatever is decided, wear it and enjoy it. Very cool watch!
Quick update. Dropped the watch in at a local shop today for a service and crystal replacement (Salt Lake City, Utah). Found the shop online and wasn't sure what to expect but it had a super relaxed and old school feel that was really cool.
After a brief chat with the owner (a one man shop) I found it very reassuring that without prompting he echoed everything the majority in this thread had recommended (give it a service, new gaskets, replace crystal.. don't refinish the body - will kill its soul). Awesome.
Quoted $650USD total (service, new crystal, new gaskets). Was actually a few hundred less than I had imaged, but understand that may change if issues are found.
After removing the back he found/confirmed it to be a 1970 Speedmaster MKII (apparently there were a gazzillion made that year), and the inner case showed there had been 5 documented services performed in its life. I didn't know marking the case that was a thing? Yeah.. Newbie.
I understand the watch is nothing particularity special in the "boutique" watch world, but the fact he put effort into keeping ticking, makes me want to do the same even more.
The shop guy also had a similar era Speedmaster with the racing dial that was in for a crystal replacement also, so I has a chance to hold and compare them side by side. The racing dial is pretty amazing.. especially with faded hands and mojo. Was great to see what a new crystal looks like (All parts were uninstalled. Ordered for the other customers racing speedy) and gave me an idea of what mine will look like. I can see how you guys get hooked on this stuff. It's a rabbit hole for sure!
Anyways... Estimated 6 to 8 weeks till it's done, but will slap some pics in the thread when I get it back. Excited to have it back in action!
Took awhile, but I received the watch back today.
...Again, I'm aware this isn't a crazy spendy or fancy piece in the watch world, but for dipping my toe in, and keeping a late family members favorite watch being worn for maybe another 50 yrs, its been totally worth it.
Any idea the condition of the pins holding the links together???
yep that would be my choice too
you would be surprised how much nicer that watch will present with just replacing the crystal and a good solid cleaning of the case and bracelet. with a clear and unblemished crystal that watch would look presentable on the wrist. Close-up pics like those in this thread don't really translate to how a watch appears when on the wrist. Going too far in a cosmetic resto will wipe out all the watch's history. i always go for "Sympathetic" restos and try to keep our stuff as-found as much as possible.
This is one for the books, well done!
I bought a MKII with no personal connection to me, and planned to restore it fully, but once it arrived I slapped it on my wrist and was done.
If a scratch tells a story, this whole watch describes a lifetime. You managed this preservation perfectly I think! Cheers!
Really well done, OP. Initially, I was thinking if you had the case restored you'd wear it more, then I recalled having my MkII re-lapped, and the first time I wore it, I put a nick in the sunburst finish 😲
https://omegaforums.net/threads/speedmaster-mark-ii-love.51132/#post-616758