Should I buy this A386 Mk I?

Posts
41
Likes
71
Hi @LouS @moyrules @subregister @TexOmega @chronoboy64 - I am a total newbie to vintage watches. Fell in love with the A386 for some odd reason 😀. Found this "A386 Mk I" on Chrono24. I've been reading all of your wonderful A386 posts. Thank you 😀. Wondering what you experts think?? Worth it at $14K USD??

Photo Source: Chrono24

Item Description:
Up for sale (only within EU) is this extremely rare 1969 Zenith El Primero A386 mark I, equiped with the iconic 3019 PHC high-beat movement, with 36,000 vibrations per hour (5 hz) permitting measurements to a tenth of a second.

The El Primero Ref. A386 has become extremely hard to find and is without any doubts the first choice for those whose collect Zenith’s watches or High frequency 1970s vintage chronographs. According to the book Zenith, by Joël Duval the model, ref. A386, was produced between 1969 and 1972, a total production of 4500 examples in stainless steel. According to the book Zenith, by Manfred Rössler, Edition Damiani, only 2500 examples of the A386 reference were produced between 1969 and 1971.
Rare, made in small quantities, well-powered with its column wheel high beat cal. 3019, the Zenith A386 has become an absolute classic. The kind of watch who immediately attracts the collector’s eyes. The watch is a true classic, which is why Zenith reissued it several years back.

Versions of the A386 model:
The model can be split into three production runs:
- The Mark I, early production series, with case no. 538DXXX to 539DXXX, estimate range in the 200 to 400, with thin sub dials hands, plain (or smooth) case back, no groove on the lugs, slightly different design from the two other mark, dial with letter P (from CHRONOGRAPH) and letter C (from AUTOMATIC) perfectly superposed, winding crown set with a four pointed star inside a circle inside case back engraved and centered, as follow, by order of appearance from top to bottom « Zenith, Swiss Made, Acier Inoxydable » (no Spillman number).

Case is untouched, minor signs or wear, hairline scratches as seen in pictures, as to be expected for a 49 year old watch.
Hour, minute, second and subdial hands are all correct to the Mark I model.
Original untouched dial and caseback (serial clearly visible). Tachy and crown are original Zenith service parts.
No known service history but the watch keeps time perfectly and all functions (start-stop-reset) work as they should (small video to show this on request).
9200519_zoom_v1552141975381.jpg 9200519b_zoom_v1552141977169.jpg 9200519c_zoom_v1552141978588.jpg 9200519d_zoom_v1552141979782.jpg 9200519g_zoom_v1552141982728.jpg
Edited:
 
Posts
1,443
Likes
3,806
MK 1 in any condition is hard to find. Not an expert but I think the price feels fair considering dial wear and service tachy scale and crown. They guys you tagged will know better and are certified experts on EPs
 
Posts
19,734
Likes
46,167
The hands look much newer than the dial, but perhaps they are just repainted and re-lumed. I'm not crazy about the look.
 
Posts
1,443
Likes
3,806
The hands look much newer than the dial, but perhaps they are just repainted and re-lumed. I'm not crazy about the look.

I agree that the color and texture are off but they do not look like service hands so relume is possible but I am also concerned when I see perfect matching patina
That said a MK1 always commands a premium over a MK 2 or 3 and don’t come to market too often below 20K
 
Posts
907
Likes
2,484
That service inner bezel would be a no no for me, and the overall condition on this one is a bit... meh...

Mark I is a bit harder to come by, but if the condition is not spot on, i would definitely go for a nicer Mark II instead. On a value aspect, a nicer MkII commands as big of a value than a average Mk I in my opinion.

Do you have a picture of the movement?
 
Posts
1,232
Likes
3,765
In theory due to rarity a MK1 in top condition would command a premium compared to a MK 2/3 in equal condition. In practice this is not something I have observed, the nuances between the MKs does not really get priced into the market much. Albeit the MK1 does not pop up often so this makes value judgements tricky. As the A386 gains in popularity and collectors learn more about them perhaps the MK1 will become highly desired over the others.

One thing is clear that as soon as any MK has issues the value drops significantly.

This particular watch the dial has enough scuffs to indicate it has been on a sloppy watchmakers bench. All hands appear to be repainted. The hour counter hand in the 6 o'clock subdial has a pointy top, other two hands are straight. The crown and tachymetre ring are service parts. The seller has not provided a movement photo. A lot of factors that would put picky collectors off.
 
Posts
209
Likes
682
I enjoy a lot Zenith vintage watches, but I am far away from being an expert, my eyes hardly see what other experts of this forum.

My general opinion for this watch is NO. Service tachymeter bezel, not including bracelet, service (and not a specific nice one) crown, and condition of the dial ... I see lot of concerns to pay a lot for this watch (and 14k of € or $ is a lot of).

I would not pay lot of money for a Mark I that is not in nice condition (and in that point, probably price would be much higher than 14k).

I would prefer a Mark II in better condition (an you probably will pay less).

In addition, congrats for seeiking for a A386, probably the most important watch from Modern Zenith (IMHO), a grail.
 
Posts
7,799
Likes
56,768
I agree with the above, with an emphasis on one/several/many fumble-fingered incursions inside. And if they couldn't be bothered to take care of the dial, I have great concerns inside, especially when no pix were shown.

Overall, an unattractive case/dial/color and an unknown but likely money pit inside. At the very least, I would expect a movement as bungled as the center post area of the dial.

But don't allow me to influence your decision😁




we need pix with all this prose.....!!!

dial.JPG MarkIII.JPG Movement.jpg

DSC02818.JPG


MarkIII
Edited:
 
Posts
1,441
Likes
11,970
I also agree with the above said. The watch is offered on C24 for a long lime now.
Seems to be not so attractive at leat with this price tag.
Best Hajo
 
Posts
1,443
Likes
3,806
pass - service scale, service dial, service main hands and two types of register hands (at least 2 of them are service)
 
Posts
907
Likes
2,484
A watch with a soft case is referred to a case that has been polished in the past, where it’s original shapes, brushing or chamfers have been polished away or altered.

In this particular watch the brushing on top of the lugs have been polished away and the case is showing a bit of soft edges where the original shape should be sharp. I was probably done at the same time it had all the service parts replaced.
Edited: