Redials: who's the man?

Posts
12,949
Likes
22,405
I would at least try cleaning the dial before going to a full redial...

Agree. Dial cleaning can be difficult as there’s a high chance of losing text. However, if you’re thinking of getting this refinished anyway, why not try removing and replacing the lacquer. If it ruins the dial, you haven’t lost anything
 
Posts
3,531
Likes
7,560
Its a tropical (milk-) chocolate dial - if it were on a Speedy many would go crazy... why is it not appreciated the same way on a Conny?
This is the madness in collecting...
 
Posts
2,606
Likes
3,044
In my opinion It is appreciated and I follow at least 2 patinated collectors on Instagram

I think it's a dire mistake on OP's end

I suggest hunting a damaged dial for the project
 
Posts
665
Likes
772
I suggest hunting a damaged dial for the project

Thanks for the suggestion. I really like the idea of sourcing another dial and have it refinished first before doing anything to the watch. It also makes it reversible if the next curator of this watch decides to reinstall the original dial. The problem now is finding a 2852 dial with stainless steel arrowhead hour markers. Regardless of condition, it can prove difficult and costly.
 
Posts
665
Likes
772
Its a tropical (milk-) chocolate dial - if it were on a Speedy many would go crazy... why is it not appreciated the same way on a Conny?
This is the madness in collecting...

Perhaps because on a sports watch like the Speedy eccentricity is more easily tolerated than on a formal dress watch.
 
Posts
3,531
Likes
7,560
Perhaps because on a sports watch like the Speedy eccentricity is more easily tolerated than on a formal dress watch.

Yes, you are right, but its a difference between just "tolerating" and grossly overpaying for a dial that's actually just degraded.
I'm aware that I am probably in the minority with my opinion, but I definitely prefer a dial that looks like it left the factory. I recall Mike´s (@MSNWatch) CK 2998 with a NOS condition dial...
 
Posts
2,606
Likes
3,044
Thanks for the suggestion. I really like the idea of sourcing another dial and have it refinished first before doing anything to the watch. It also makes it reversible if the next curator of this watch decides to reinstall the original dial. The problem now is finding a 2852 dial with stainless steel arrowhead hour markers. Regardless of condition, it can prove difficult and costly.

PM’ed you regarding the dial

It’s definitely possible with patience

Also another suggestion is being very careful and specifying everything, if they provide a service too, you could receive a polished watch in the process

So it’s a good idea to make sure it’s only the dial getting the treatment, usually these people go for complete destruction, polishing even the hands
 
Posts
665
Likes
772
PM’ed you regarding the dial

It’s definitely possible with patience

Also another suggestion is being very careful and specifying everything, if they provide a service too, you could receive a polished watch in the process

So it’s a good idea to make sure it’s only the dial getting the treatment, usually these people go for complete destruction, polishing even the hands

Thanks. That's great advice and it looks like that's one more reason to only send them the dial and nothing else.
 
Posts
1,072
Likes
1,482
So interesting how we collectors differ so much. I find your dial stunning.