Redials: who's the man?

Posts

691

Likes

832

bananapeanut

·Oct 18, 2022

I'd like to have the dial of a vintage Connie repainted in a dark blue tone (Korea style like the Genèves they sell on eBay). However, I'm having a hard time finding a good dial refinisher. In your opinion, who's the best dial refinisher in the US?

Edited: Oct 18, 2022

 

Posts

13,483

Likes

31,782

X350 XJR

·Oct 18, 2022·Vintage Omega Aficionado

https://lsdials.com/

Good work reasonable prices.

 

Posts

691

Likes

832

bananapeanut

·Oct 18, 2022

X350 XJR

https://lsdials.com/

Good work reasonable prices.

Thanks! I'll get in touch with them

 

Posts

285

Likes

221

Ocean

·Oct 19, 2022

I am just curios how your dial will look after this redial. Maybe you will post some pictures later here.

 

Posts

691

Likes

832

bananapeanut

·Oct 19, 2022

Ocean

I am just curios how your dial will look after this redial.

I'm hoping in this kind of dark blue color:

but on the same reference as that one:

 

Posts

5,001

Likes

18,559

Shabbaz

·Oct 19, 2022

Could you post pictures of the end result? Thnx

 

Posts

34,853

Likes

39,423

dsio

·Oct 19, 2022·Ash @ ΩF

That could actually come out looking really superb. Redial or not it’ll look awesome on the wrist.

 

Posts

29,894

Likes

77,322

Archer

·Oct 19, 2022·Omega Qualified Watchmaker

Interesting date window border on the El Primero dial they have on the front page...

 

Posts

6,800

Likes

54,001

noelekal

·Oct 19, 2022·Home For Wayward Watches

Before and after photos would be nice.

 

Posts

691

Likes

832

bananapeanut

·Oct 19, 2022

The hands will have to be refinished too.

Edited: Oct 27, 2022

 

Posts

898

Likes

1,652

Bruce235

·Oct 19, 2022

Agree that you will not be losing much from a redial. The blue will look good.

 

Posts

691

Likes

832

bananapeanut

·Oct 19, 2022

Archer

Interesting date window border on the El Primero dial they have on the front page...

Good catch, and you see that's the problem with dial refinishers, even the examples they showcase on their website are not always 100% convincing. If that's their best work, it makes you wonder what their average work looks like. That said, the El Primero has a more complex dial than the Connie.

Edited: Oct 19, 2022

 

Posts

6,800

Likes

54,001

noelekal

·Oct 19, 2022·Home For Wayward Watches

Thanks bananapeanut.

As is, that dial doesn't have much to recommend ir.

 

Posts

385

Likes

1,924

UWG

·Oct 19, 2022

bananapeanut

For now, here is the BEFORE photo:

View attachment 1493974

The hands will have to be refinished too.

If you ask me, that dial is a "real" one.
Quite evenly patinated and interesting / good looking in my eyes. I would leave it as it is. I think the Connie will lose its character.

 

Posts

29,894

Likes

77,322

Archer

·Oct 19, 2022·Omega Qualified Watchmaker

UWG

If you ask me, that dial is a "real" one.
Quite evenly patinated and interesting / good looking in my eyes. I would leave it as it is. I think the Connie will lose its character.

I would at least try cleaning the dial before going to a full redial...

 

Posts

499

Likes

966

pmontoyap

·Oct 19, 2022

I beg to differ on this one. That dial is in original condition and that is most likely tabacco build up. Even as it is I think it tells a story, a more interesting one that what the repainted dial will say.

I am sure there are a few expert watchmakers that can clean that up with their little magic recipe. I know a couple in the UK, and ages ago I read an article about a restoration by a guy in Miami but all I can recall is he had a last name of Indian heritage.

 

Posts

385

Likes

1,924

UWG

·Oct 19, 2022

And even the condition of the hands are matching with the dial. It would not bother me.
Just another leather strap...

 

Posts

7,724

Likes

14,296

Evitzee

·Oct 19, 2022

bananapeanut

Good catch, and you see that's the problem with dial refinishers, even the examples they showcase on their website are not always 100% convincing. If that's their best work, it makes you wonder what their average work looks like. That said, the El Primero has a more complex dial than the Connie.

The 'before' pic had the same treatment around the date window so all the refinisher did was duplicate what was already on the dial.

 

Posts

29,894

Likes

77,322

Archer

·Oct 19, 2022·Omega Qualified Watchmaker

Evitzee

The 'before' pic had the same treatment around the date window so all the refinisher did was duplicate what was already on the dial.

Nope - you are missing the spot that is very different...

 

Posts

6,800

Likes

54,001

noelekal

·Oct 19, 2022·Home For Wayward Watches

I'd be willing to make the attempt to have the dial cleaned before going the re-dial route. If it wouldn't clean up or was further ruined then a refinish would be in order

Nothing ventured, nothing gained.