Community Stories

Recommended Zenith Watches On Ebay (Not Inquires)

haga888
Posts
443
Likes
1,600
Reg Reg
How about this Mk1 A 386? 'HA' type dial and hands all look original. Shame about the naff undersized crown though. How easy is it to get replacement crowns and crystal?

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/201146237168?_trksid=p2055119.m1438.l2649&ssPageName=STRK:MEBIDX:IT

70457

That didn't go cheap. 4,000 pounds.
 
This website may earn commission from Ebay sales.
Stewart H
Posts
3,070
Likes
3,528
I have deliberately kept quiet on this one and would ask why it was ever posted in the "Recommended Zenith" thread.

Last Saturday, I went to see this watch and whilst it is not the worst A386 I have seen, it has very few endearing qualities. OK, two. The dial is good and it checks out as a first series watch.

If you look closely at the photos, you will see that half of one of the screw heads on the rotating weight is broken off - this will be a really time consuming task to remove, before you even start to dismantle the movement. The chrono will not run for a full minute, so it is impossible to tell if the re-set works. The hands need replacing as does the tachy ring (as noted above) There are also other issues with the movement.

My guess is that the minimum the buyer will have to spend on it to make it half way decent is £1,500 without replacing the tachy ring and hands - if you can get them.

I would have been prepared to offer the seller £3,000 but I knew it would end up at £4 - 4.5 K

It is a big gamble for someone and I hope it pays off for them but watch out for 539D175.
 
Queue
Posts
79
Likes
139
Stewart H Stewart H
I have deliberately kept quiet on this one and would ask why it was ever posted in the "Recommended Zenith" thread.

Last Saturday, I went to see this watch and whilst it is not the worst A386 I have seen, it has very few endearing qualities. OK, two. The dial is good and it checks out as a first series watch.

If you look closely at the photos, you will see that half of one of the screw heads on the rotating weight is broken off - this will be a really time consuming task to remove, before you even start to dismantle the movement. The chrono will not run for a full minute, so it is impossible to tell if the re-set works. The hands need replacing as does the tachy ring (as noted above) There are also other issues with the movement.

My guess is that the minimum the buyer will have to spend on it to make it half way decent is £1,500 without replacing the tachy ring and hands - if you can get them.

I would have been prepared to offer the seller £3,000 but I knew it would end up at £4 - 4.5 K

It is a big gamble for someone and I hope it pays off for them but watch out for 539D175.

I won the watch. The info about what needs to be fixed on the watch is very helpful actually, thank you. I'll be sure to forward it to the watchmaker (most likely ABC Watchwerks), who will be dismantling and cleaning the piece for me at some point in the future. If you have any more info, definitely let me know.

I wanted a Mark I for my personal collection. If all I have to spend is 1500 GBP, then I'll be very pleased indeed. I didn't buy it to resell it. I bought it because it is a rare piece of history, and those are the kinds of pieces I like having in my collection. I bid based on projecting what it would cost to overhaul it completely and replace parts.

I'm not sure why you would say "watch out for 539D175"?

If you bought this piece for the £3000 you were thinking of offering the seller and then fixed it up, as I'm guessing it would have been worth your while to do so at £3000, how would you feel if someone else referenced and besmirched your watch that way in a public forum? Probably pretty rotten I'd guess... 🙁

Imagine you were able to buy it at the price you wanted of £3000, and someone who wanted to buy it at £2000 decided to then besmirch the watch on a forum after the fact. How would that look to you?
 
D
Posts
0
Likes
7,038
I don't think Stewart is trying to besmirch your purchase at all, or potential purchase. As he said he would of been prepared to buy the watch, which stands for something, right? If the watch was truly what you wanted for your collection, then why worry what anyone else thinks? You should just be happy and enjoy the watch. There will always be a plus and minus about a purchase, this is a very subjective field.

We will look forward to see it after its well deserved spa treatment! 😀
 
MMMD
Posts
4,642
Likes
31,206
Congrats and good luck getting it in order. There will be no curse upon the case number if you can set it right... nay, it will be covered in glory.
Those 0-feedback "bidders" are so irritating; I'm glad he didn't gouge you for more than £5.
 
JohnSteed
Posts
4,402
Likes
5,797
D Dablitzer
I don't think Stewart is trying to besmirch your purchase at all, or potential purchase. As he said he would of been prepared to buy the watch, which stands for something, right? If the watch was truly what you wanted for your collection, then why worry what anyone else thinks? You should just be happy and enjoy the watch. There will always be a plus and minus about a purchase, this is a very subjective field.

We will look forward to see it after it's well deserved spa treatment! 😀



+ 1 and it would be great to see it here after the spa treatment.

My guess is, it'll look great. Enjoy!!
 
Queue
Posts
79
Likes
139
D Dablitzer
I don't think Stewart is trying to besmirch your purchase at all, or potential purchase. As he said he would of been prepared to buy the watch, which stands for something, right? If the watch was truly what you wanted for your collection, then why worry what anyone else thinks? You should just be happy and enjoy the watch. There will always be a plus and minus about a purchase, this is a very subjective field.

We will look forward to see it after its well deserved spa treatment! 😀
JohnSteed JohnSteed
+ 1 and it would be great to see it here after the spa treatment.

My guess is, it'll look great. Enjoy!!



MMMD MMMD
Congrats and good luck getting it in order. There will be no curse upon the case number if you can set it right... nay, it will be covered in glory.
Those 0-feedback "bidders" are so irritating; I'm glad he didn't gouge you for more than £5.


Thanks guys. I guess idea that at some point down the road, if I have a run of bad luck and go broke, and have to sell some or all of my collection, that someone could see this thread and think there is something permanently wrong with this piece worried me. That is why I responded to the post. I agree, if all is expertly fixed then all is well with the piece.

I will definitely post pics after it has its spa treatment!

In the meantime, if anyone has any parts I need for the piece, I'm looking for a period correct crown (or close to it in the interim), tachy insert, and possibly hands. With the hands I may just try to look into patching the original hand that is missing lume and then fix the back, so I don't want lume mismatch between the hands and dial.

If anyone thinks of any useful info or advice on restoring this piece in ways that will not be intrusive or destructive to its originality, please message me! I'd really appreciate it!
 
Reg
Posts
19
Likes
6
Stewart H Stewart H
The hands need replacing

Why do the hands need replacing? They appear to be original. A bit of TLC and relume would be preferable to replacing them wouldn't it?
 
Stewart H
Posts
3,070
Likes
3,528
Reg Reg
Why do the hands need replacing? They appear to be original. A bit of TLC and relume would be preferable to replacing them wouldn't it?
You are right. It just depends on how original you want to keep it. My personal preference is for original lume rather than re-luming, so I try to source replacement vintage hands for my watches where this is necessary. It is, relatively speaking, easier to pick up the hour & minute hands, but the sweep second hand is rarer than hens teeth.
 
Reg
Posts
19
Likes
6
Thanks Stewart. I agree that it would've been nice if the original hands had been in good condition. And I guess the debate on vintage but non-original parts vs sympathetically restored original parts would go on forever, so thank you for sharing your perspective on what you try to achieve with your own watches.
 
Andsan
Posts
1,673
Likes
26,819
Exelent condition. With steel bracelet too 😀

What will this cost?

I have the exact same day but without this bracelet
 
D
Posts
0
Likes
7,038
Andsan Andsan
Exelent condition. With steel bracelet too 😀

What will this cost?

I have the exact same day but without this bracelet
it's definately not going to stay low now! 😀
 
Darlinboy
Posts
8,742
Likes
69,414
D Dablitzer
it's definately not going to stay low now! 😀

True, but surely the vetting here is worth something in peace of mind.

I have found it so on a couple of occasions.
 
D
Posts
0
Likes
7,038
Darlinboy Darlinboy
True, but surely the vetting here is worth something in peace of mind.

I have found it so on a couple of occasions.
Yes, I have no doubt the vetting here is immeasuable! 😀 I was just being facetious..😗
 
Darlinboy
Posts
8,742
Likes
69,414
D Dablitzer
Yes, I have no doubt the vetting here is immeasuable! 😀 I was just being facetious..😗


Some of us need it more than others, I am still an Omega tyro. 😉


As an aside, I strongly suspect certain others on this very forum (you know who you are!) are a not insignificant factor many of the higher market prices we've seen lately. 😝
 
khmt2
Posts
1,632
Likes
14,545
Andsan Andsan
Exelent condition. With steel bracelet too 😀

What will this cost?

I have the exact same day but without this bracelet

747 GBP! Was that a reasonable price considering the condition and the original bracelet?
 
MMMD
Posts
4,642
Likes
31,206
khmt2 khmt2
747 GBP! Was that a reasonable price considering the condition and the original bracelet?

Yes, I think so.
 
361 More Posts...
Sign up or log in to reply...

Similar threads

MMMD

Not Recommended Zenith Watches

MMMD Zenith Watches
m neuman
m neuman
Posts
52
Views
14K