I really like the look of leather strap on dress watches and some sports watches, but never had great luck with OEM or aftermarket straps.
They tend to literally break down or become so discoloured that they are just about unusable after about a year. I am certainly open to spending a good chunk of change on a strap that can last with good care.

Any recommendations regarding:
Type of leather?
Brand?
Leather care products?

 

You might try the Omega black alligator over rubber with deployment buckle. Worked great on my PO.

 

I do know about the hybrid strap and rubber strap options.

But alas, I was cursed with pediatric wrists. The rubber and hybrid straps tend to be bulky and add to the lug to lug.

I would prefer pure leather straps that fare better than the Amazon straps.

 

24 pages of recommendations:
https://omegaforums.net/threads/«wa...-buy-good-quality-leather-watch-straps.82232/

 

Nice, thank you. Will sieve through this one.

 

Been in the game for a few years.

SNPR straps….

 

I like shell cordovan. It’s soft and formable from the beginning. Also ages nicely. Have ordered made to measure from watchstrapheaven. He makes them by hand.
Few pics for inspiration.

 

Should add that I like un-padded straps. They give a more classy look imo.

 

Omega SpeedMaster Professional with an alligator leather strap and Omega Clasp buckle.
https://www.omegawatches.com/en-us/omega-watch-straps-black-alligator-leather-strap-032cuz007467w


The following picture is from Topper......

 

I get your struggle with leather straps! It can be frustrating when they don't hold up well over time.

 

I've owned a number of OEM and other straps. The most comfortable is Omega Rally strap.

 

Some tips on leather care?

 

I totally get your struggle with leather watch straps!

 

The black croc on deployment just looks right to me

 

In my experience, shell cordovan, teju lizard and crocodile hold up the best.

 

There are many independent strap makers nowadays which produce high quality straps and can be found in social media (Instagram etc).

 

https://www.genteel-handmade.com/
All you need to know.

 

For a durable option, check out Von Baer's guide on leather tanning at https://vonbaer.com/blogs/blog/what-is-leather-tanning. It might help you understand the type of leather to look for. They also offer high-quality leather goods and care products that could extend the lifespan of your watch straps.