Played My Drums Wearing My Aqua Terra... yeah, don't

Posts
29,671
Likes
76,828
why would a mechanism that winds a watch speed up the time keeping?

It won't, unless there's a fault. When an automatic watch is worn, the mainspring is at full wind for most of the day if you are active, so adding more wind won't cause a fast rate, unless the mainspring is not slipping in the barrel properly. If the mainspring doesn't slip when it should, it's possible for the spring to impart more torque to the movement than it was designed for. This will increase the balance amplitude, and cause the watch to go into a condition called rebanking. This is a state where the balance amplitude is so high, that the impulse pin (roller jewel) travels too far, and strikes the outside of the pallet fork horn, and it "bounces" off that in the other direction. This returns the balance the opposite direction faster that the balance spring would normally do so, and if the torque level stays too high, it will bounces back the other way. This can result in a very fast rate - this is also sometimes called knocking, or even galloping, because it sounds a bit like a galloping horse. Here's a video - I'm taking a full wound watch and turning the crown even further to make it rebank:


Again, this only happens when the mainspring isn't slipping as it should. If the watch runs normally when fully wound, it is unlikely to be this that is causing a fast rate.

In this instance, it is likely just inertia. Whenever you move your wrist while wearing a watch, you will impart external forces on the balance. Depending on what direction that force is going compared to how the balance is moving, it may either add of subtract from the forces moving the balance. If it adds, it can again cause excessive amplitude, and this will result in timekeeping changes.

Even if I take a watch and put it on my timing machine, and turn the microphone stand quickly, the rate will jump all over the place until it settles (rate resumption). If you are wearing a watch while constantly making forceful movement like playing the drums, it's not too surprising that the timekeeping may be off. BTW, in this case it doesn't matter if it's an automatic or manual wind watch.

Cheers, Al
 
Posts
18,202
Likes
27,530
@Archer thanks for the wonderful explanation and for the record I was asking a rhetorical question馃榾
 
Posts
29,671
Likes
76,828
@Archer thanks for the wonderful explanation and for the record I was asking a rhetorical question馃榾

Great, and for the record I was simply using your post as a jumping off point to answer the non-rhetorical questions in the thread. 馃榾
 
Posts
6,832
Likes
13,797
Great, and for the record I was simply using your post as a jumping off point to answer the non-rhetorical questions in the thread. 馃榾
And for the record I enjoyed the non-rhetorical answers to the non-rhetorical questions that where answered from the rhetorical springboard question posted by Foo2rama
 
Posts
9,737
Likes
54,446
And for the record I enjoyed the non-rhetorical answers to the non-rhetorical questions that where answered from the rhetorical springboard question posted by Foo2rama
Gentlemen, your collective horological brilliance is giving the less cerebral among us (i.e., me) a headache, but it makes for very interesting reading. 馃榾
 
Posts
3,535
Likes
8,863
As a scientific experiment [*] I took a beater phone (broken screen) with a sensor reading app and tapped it against my other hand. Prolly a lot less effort than would make much sound from a drum. Read at 40G !

Now, if I put forward a proposal for real research in this area to glue the phone to a watch and buy a drum-kit would I get the funding? The world needs this information 馃槑


[*] OK, more of an engineer's experiment.
 
Posts
1,245
Likes
4,777
Why do sound engineers say " one, two. one two"?

Because if they said "one, two, three, four" they would be drummers.
have fun
kfw
 
Posts
420
Likes
885
What do you call the guy that hangs around with the band?

The drummer.

What do you call a drummer that broke up with his girlfriend?

Homeless.
 
Posts
4,816
Likes
12,194
What an endorsement for Omega鈥檚 toughness!! On a serious note, have to the gun range many times with various Omegas (PO and Speedy)..............no problem.

Pistols or rifles? I would think pistols are harder on watches.
 
Posts
42
Likes
29
If you shake a watch fast, it speeds up. I thought it was a product of the rotor going faster than intended. If so, wearing a Speedy would be better for the drums... maybe Archer can chime in if this phenomenon is specific to automatic watches.

Whatever it鈥檚 worth, I typically wear my Aquaracer (Calibre 5) to the gym. if I do battle ropes it鈥檚 not unusual for it to be a little fast, 20-30 seconds maybe, but certainly not entire minutes.

It's most likely caused by relativity.