Opinions on worn or near to perfect

Wakaman · Dec 28, 2025

I have been offered this 135.027 Seamaster 120. And as you can see it has lived a life. I'm guessing it is from around 1970, and has recently been serviced but clearly little on the exterior has been changed (having said - the case looks like it could have been swapped). I have 166.027, from 68, which is near perfect condition and I've always sought out the very best I could afford. But this little fella has taken on a different look completely and, while somewhat conflicted, I am really warming to it? What's the thought - better staying on near as perfect when collecting as you can, or loving the look of a watch that has been fully used ?

Davidt · Dec 28, 2025

Personally I’d take little enjoyment from that dial.

Sometimes years of wear can result in a really attractive patina or aesthetic that do provide a nice alternative to a watch in mint condition. This isn’t one of those times.

Larry S · Dec 28, 2025

Davidt
Personally I’d take little enjoyment from that dial.

Sometimes years of wear can result in a really attractive patina or aesthetic that do provide a nice alternative to a watch in mint condition. This isn’t one of those times.

+1 … The dial / hands need more TLC than I’d care to invest. That said, everyone has different taste.

Dan S · Dec 28, 2025

All things being equal, I don't like moldy lume. But if it's dirt cheap and you would get pleasure from wearing it, then go for it.

Evitzee · Dec 28, 2025

If you can be happy looking at that dial and hands, fine. Everyone's different, but I see no joy in it.

Porteroso · Dec 28, 2025

I would for sure relume the dial and hands, if I was buying. When it's that far gone, no point in saving the moldy lume. However we all enjoy something or another that's all beat up. Totally personal preference.

Opinions on worn or near to perfect

Wakaman

Davidt

Larry S

Dan S

Evitzee

Porteroso

Similar threads

Worn or wobbly coupling wheel on 321?

Advice for UG watchmaker in Switzerland north Italy or near Dusseldorf please.

Omega Speedmaster 3572 Tritium Near Mint with Perfect Patina and 1863 Rhodium Movement - Full Set

Near Perfect mint Omega Seamaster 120 Diver 136.027 w papers

Trusted watchmaker for Speedmaster Pro in Southwestern Ontario or near Detroit Michigan

NOS Omega 1035 Speedmaster/ Seamaster 300 bracelet, never restored or refinished and near perfect