Omega vintage opinions

Posts
28
Likes
8
Hi gents,
This watch the seller says that is serviced, but like you can see there is some rust in the movement:


What is your opinion?

Thank you for your help.

Regards
 
Posts
12,585
Likes
16,980
My opinion is that rust is like cancer. You can clean it up inside of the movement, but there is a good likelihood it will return.

Especially with all the rust on the case.

I would pass on this example.
gatorcpa
 
Posts
1,173
Likes
2,435
What do you see? I'm no expert but if the dial is usually that clean it has been redialed. I'll give some advice too. Lots of members on OF love to give advice but it comes with the idea that the OP is putting in research and doing their homework. Start with this
 
Posts
28
Likes
8
What do you see? I'm no expert but if the dial is usually that clean it has been redialed. I'll give some advice too. Lots of members on OF love to give advice but it comes with the idea that the OP is putting in research and doing their homework. Start with this
What I see is that the dial is too clean for a watch from about 1944 like the seller says.
I would like from people with more experience what they think, I already know that re dial watches loose value, so I think is a no, but I really like it.
Also the movement I would like to have a opinion from someone with experience, from my eyes looks ok....

And thank you for the link.

Thank you regards.
 
Posts
588
Likes
2,930
Hi Cooper, in theory people would ask you to post another thread if you ask about another watch.

Also, it would be nice if you could point out your own opinion on the watch instead of just asking if everything looks legit.

In this particular case, I can see who is trying to sell you this watch (Maximilian from VP).

I would like to show you this.

https://omegaforums.net/threads/ev3rclears-5th-attempt.23947/#post-263373

Be careful when dealing with this person.

Best,

Rudi
 
Posts
4,593
Likes
10,791
Seems like a whole lot of unwritten rules lately?

Hi Cooper, in theory people would ask you to post another thread if you ask about another watch.

Also, it would be nice if you could point out your own opinion on the watch instead of just asking if everything looks legit.

I'll just go ahead and answer the OP's queries with my opinions like most would...

Watch 1 as previously pointed out appears to have terminal rust issues.

Watch 2 is most likely a redial

Watch3 seems to be the most original example shown so far despite whoever is selling it.
 
Posts
588
Likes
2,930
Seems like a whole lot of unwritten rules lately?



I'll just go ahead and answer the OP's queries with my opinions like most would...

Watch 1 as previously pointed out appears to have terminal rust issues.

Watch 2 is most likely a redial

Watch3 seems to be the most original example shown so far despite whoever is selling it.

Just thought it would be more organised for the future if other people would try and gather information. Didn't mean to bully or be dictating any rule.

I thought that would have been better, but hey, you are the most experienced and knowledged, not to mention the better-looking of us both, I think people should indeed rather listen to you. 👍
 
Posts
4,593
Likes
10,791
you are the most experienced and knowledged, not to mention the better-looking of us both, I think people should indeed rather listen to you.

Now you're talkin! 👍
 
Posts
375
Likes
465
Now for exemple about this one everything looks legitim?:

Regards.
Also depends on the asking price for the watches.
 
Posts
28
Likes
8
Also depends on the asking price for the watches.
The seamaster 750€.
The 30T2 800€.
Like we all know this is tricky because for example for me the re-dailing of the the 30T2 doesn´t bother me too much and I like it like this, but the problem is I think of it as an investment as well and this kind of watches on these days are more expensive than a few years ago.

Basically and for conclusion my point of view, give 800€ for a watch that for some reason in the future I might need to sell it I know that I´m gonna loose money becasue isn´t in the conditions that should be or the watch collectors don´t aprecciate. And if they were more cheaper I could think on buy them like they are, but with those prices I don´t give the chance.

Well I need to be patience and keep "fishing" and my anniversaire present needs to keep wating until I find the "Holy grail"....

Thank you for your help.
 
Posts
4,593
Likes
10,791
Well I need to be patience and keep "fishing" and my anniversaire present needs to keep wating until I find the "Holy grail"

Well I don't know about "holy grail" but with some hunting and researching you certainly can come up with a very pleasant keeper in relatively short order. I would suggest watching the sales threads on this site as a safe hunting ground 👍
 
Posts
28
Likes
8
It's no being easy, I do research in several sites, I don't know if I can write them in here.,but in all the I search the ones that I liked and post them in here failures.. So far and nothing new on those sites so... Well...
If can send me for private or in here some sites that are safe please let me know...

Thank you
 
Posts
588
Likes
2,930
Hey Cooper,

Don't feel so disencouraged. You are doing the right thing and researching the best you can.

I spent two months researching a lot of different websites and even after that some weeks asking people here for help regarding the purchase of my first two vintage watches.

I invested a lot of time after work just looking through hundreds of vintage Omegas but it was worth it and people here helped a lot.

My original goal was a 50s Seamaster and even after 3 to 4 months looking after a good one at a reasonable price, only recently I was able to trace one. If you hang around long enough, you will surely be able to find what you are looking for.
 
Posts
20,663
Likes
47,498
The seamaster 750€.
The 30T2 800€.
Like we all know this is tricky because for example for me the re-dailing of the the 30T2 doesn´t bother me too much and I like it like this, but the problem is I think of it as an investment as well and this kind of watches on these days are more expensive than a few years ago.

Basically and for conclusion my point of view, give 800€ for a watch that for some reason in the future I might need to sell it I know that I´m gonna loose money becasue isn´t in the conditions that should be or the watch collectors don´t aprecciate. And if they were more cheaper I could think on buy them like they are, but with those prices I don´t give the chance.

Well I need to be patience and keep "fishing" and my anniversaire present needs to keep wating until I find the "Holy grail"....

Thank you for your help.

I don't really like to hear newbies talking about investments. It's hard enough to find a collectible watch in good condition. Trying to find a bargain that will go up in value that is also a collectible watch in good condition just makes your task next to impossible. Especially if you are limiting yourself to the internet. Every collector in the world is looking at the same watches.

If you want to buy yourself a nice present, then don't worry too much about spending an extra 200 euros if you find a good watch that will give you joy. We're not talking about life-changing money.
 
Posts
1,541
Likes
3,349
The seamaster 750€.
The 30T2 800€.
Like we all know this is tricky because for example for me the re-dailing of the the 30T2 doesn´t bother me too much and I like it like this, but the problem is I think of it as an investment as well and this kind of watches on these days are more expensive than a few years ago.

Basically and for conclusion my point of view, give 800€ for a watch that for some reason in the future I might need to sell it I know that I´m gonna loose money becasue isn´t in the conditions that should be or the watch collectors don´t aprecciate. And if they were more cheaper I could think on buy them like they are, but with those prices I don´t give the chance.

Well I need to be patience and keep "fishing" and my anniversaire present needs to keep wating until I find the "Holy grail"....

Thank you for your help.
One of the first things I learned here is that this is essentially a community of collectors. Yes, there are dealers here, and some collectors sell here, but the collectors tend to do it to make room or raise funds for another watch. There’s very little talk here of buying for investment, because very few people here are in it for investment purposes.

Furthermore, as collectors, the people here probably know far more about a watch’s history and quality than its investment value. There are several people here who are living encyclopedias when it comes to watches, but they are not able to see the future, and for the most part, they’re not interested in what a watch is going to be worth.

Of course, there are many people here, I’m sure, who have bought watches with a hope, a view, and even an expectation that it will increase in value. I doubt many of these people are putting their pension provision in their watch collection, however. I’m guessing that they are using other financial vehicles as investments.

For the most part, people here complain about how prices are being driven up by speculators, so it’s not the place to ask for speculation advice.

So, my two pennyworth is to repeat the advice that probably comes up here on a daily basis - buy it because you like it, pay for it what you want to pay for it, and enjoy it. If you want to buy for long term financial gain you’re pretty much on your own, because nobody really knows what a good investment is, the best you’ll get here is someone’s idea of a bad buy.
 
Posts
1,862
Likes
2,539
I don't really like to hear newbies talking about investments. It's hard enough to find a collectible watch in good condition. Trying to find a bargain that will go up in value that is also a collectible watch in good condition just makes your task next to impossible. Especially if you are limiting yourself to the internet. Every collector in the world is looking at the same watches.

If you want to buy yourself a nice present, then don't worry too much about spending an extra 200 euros if you find a good watch that will give you joy. We're not talking about life-changing money.

👍👍👍
 
Posts
537
Likes
356
Nothing wrong with buying a redialed watch .... if you like it and it's priced properly. Thats why showing the price they are asking when you show a watch for comments is important. It goes without saying that posting poor photos does not help anyone help you.

You won't be able to sell a redialed watch to a collector for a profit because a watch collector won't want to buy it period.

That should not stop you from buying and wearing a redialed watch. IMO a watch dial can NEVER look "too good".