Omega Speedmaster 2998-1 on an auction - A Franken!

Posts
1,555
Likes
3,183
Hi Forum Friends!

I normally post my Speedy auctions after the sale, but this watch is so weird and a true Frankenwatch,
so I wanted to warn some potential novice buyer (that hopefully reads this…),
and also share with the rest of you of course!


It is stated as a 2998-1, with 100% original parts….🙁

Here is a link to the auction:
https://www.catawiki.com/en/l/88529321-omega-speedmaster-2998-1-unisex-1960-1969

The ”Expert” has an estimate of 20000-22000 €!
And somebody has already placed a bid.

Looking at the pictures, there could not be many original 2998-1 parts.

The movement could be for a 2998-1, but the rest??

I found at least 6 parts (the hands count as one…) that are not correct for this reference, but the most obvious one is the dial.
And the caseback must be a fake/rebranded one!

Enjoy the pictures, and please do comment!






fadace19-5c22-4efc-b8ba-91a42d0e0f50.jpg e844232b-f7d6-422a-85c8-512d2923b6fe.jpg f0edda07-3183-43c8-aabb-43094538e452.jpg 5e91f0cc-e314-42a1-aaee-5a6149a96ea6.jpg af5cc7c4-7f03-49d8-9499-7ef3f39ad9a5.jpg 530dc564-ea09-4d3e-97b6-7e9aefaddb1e.jpg 76e7ae5a-2317-41fc-8c64-5ac446c04db4.jpg 54f6fdb8-7d2e-4814-8c6b-445dd85974a8.jpg 213166c0-4add-43b2-81db-1b44350f7ff2.jpg 444884ec-0017-4155-942e-d9201b7e7eb9.jpg d21fef5e-ff2a-4898-8b0e-8a43ae4a0f75.jpg
 
Posts
19,776
Likes
46,217
The caseback is especially weird. How was that done?
 
Posts
1,555
Likes
3,183
They must have polished down the original ref, and then stamped a new one?
Comparing to a true original, there are som difference in the "polish paterns".

28_20230326091648_6721793_large.jpg
 
Posts
5,250
Likes
8,181
Catawiki never lets you down
 
Posts
339
Likes
341
They must have polished down the original ref, and then stamped a new one?
Comparing to a true original, there are som difference in the "polish paterns".

28_20230326091648_6721793_large.jpg
They must have polished down the original ref, and then stamped a new one?
Comparing to a true original, there are som difference in the "polish paterns".

28_20230326091648_6721793_large.jpg

I think they would have filled in the old stamping, turned or machined that area and then stamped. The stamping are quite deep, and that would be a lot of material to remove.

Or is that what you meant?
 
Posts
11,061
Likes
19,461
Looks like one of the rare occasions or see a repainted speedmaster dial
 
Posts
143
Likes
97
Let's hope that the current bidder reads this post including someone at Catawiki.
 
Posts
196
Likes
148
Wow. I am about as non expert as anyone here, and I started shaking my head as soon as I saw the first picture. This is ridiculous, even by Catawiki standards.
 
Posts
1,555
Likes
3,183
It would have been interesting to talk to the Expert Erwin Dekker.....???😁

Skärmavbild 2024-09-26 kl. 13.54.22.png
 
Posts
5,250
Likes
8,181
Erwin’s only target is turnover. At CW the level of knowledge of the experts is - judging by what they auction - not much higher than ‘pretty basic’
 
Posts
1,555
Likes
3,183
Erwin’s only target is turnover. At CW the level of knowledge of the experts is - judging by what they auction - not much higher than ‘pretty basic’
Give the guy some cred....
He is fully focused on watches....😂

Skärmavbild 2024-09-27 kl. 15.33.55.png
 
Posts
339
Likes
341
I guess the question is, what is the value of the parts?
 
Posts
5,250
Likes
8,181
Factoring in the 9% buyer protection 😀:facepalm1:😀 I assume we are already beyond that
 
Posts
868
Likes
1,621
How does the CW search function work ??
It must have some automatic safety guard for junk watches because If i enter ; omega+2998 , it gives no results. And Speedmaster+2998 gives 194 results so it is burrried somewhere in there. It will not find many buyers this way, a good thing !
 
Posts
456
Likes
718
its is a pro seller though, so 14 day right of withdrawal will apply