Omega cosmic dial originality question

Posts
9
Likes
1
Found listed at 12,500. $ feels very steep. Website says original dial. What would you pay
dea6ce_eceb4485b01f4d51a442342f3c932dd6~mv2.jpg
 
Posts
13,202
Likes
22,960
What are your thoughts on overall condition?
Have you found any comparable sales listing or sold prices?
 
Posts
3,402
Likes
13,196
A quick research of the seller - the Omega Enthusiast - will tell you what you need to know about his products (great quality) and his prices (a few times market value). There are even threads on the forum about this.
 
Posts
9
Likes
1
What are your thoughts on overall condition?
Have you found any comparable sales listing or sold prices?
quality looks good hard to compare apples to apples. not seeing a lot of originals like this
 
Posts
9
Likes
1
A quick research of the seller - the Omega Enthusiast - will tell you what you need to know about his products (great quality) and his prices (a few times market value). There are even threads on the forum about this.
what would you say 2471 is worth. would 12500 be drastically overpaying
 
Posts
3,402
Likes
13,196
what would you say 2471 is worth. would 12500 be drastically overpaying

Yes, very much so. Have you checked eBay for sold items? Even on Chrono24 - the world's largest watch market - you'll find 16 hits if you search for "Omega 2471". Note that those are available, meaning that nobody has yet been willing to meet the sellers' asking prices.

But it's your choice. The alternatives are investing a lot of time or settling for a lesser quality.

Good price, good quality, good availability. Pick two. That's how the game works, I'm afraid.
 
Posts
13,483
Likes
31,778
"The case back does show some light dings and appears to have been sanded."

"appears to have been sanded." = This is the best I could do to remove the severe pitting.

Looks like a moon rock would be more accurate.
Edited:
 
Posts
9
Likes
1
Yes, very much so. Have you checked eBay for sold items?

But it's your choice. The alternatives are investing a lot of time or settling for a lesser quality.

Good price, good quality, good availability. Pick two. That's how the game works, I'm afraid.

thats helpful. the quality seems great. but I’m not hurried to make the purchase and willing to invest the time for a better price. fear it’ll be hard to find the same quality though

I need to look more at eBay.
 
Posts
9
Likes
1
"The case back does show some light dings and appears to have been sanded."

"appears to have been sanded." = This is the best I could do to get the severe pitting out.

Looks like a moon rock would be more accurate.
feels like this model is difficult to get in mint condition. but price should be reflected of that. this is in really good quality compared to others I’ve seen. but feel like $8k is more appropriate. am I crazy?
 
Posts
1,447
Likes
3,018
I had one of these and I sold it $4300 this time last year. It was all original but had one mark on the dial. Otherwise perfect and all working condition. I think a price around $5000 would be suitable.
 
Posts
9
Likes
1
I had one of these and I sold it $4300 this time last year. It was all original but had one mark on the dial. Otherwise perfect and all working condition. I think a price around $5000 would be suitable.

oh wow! any chance you’d have another at some point to sell? any pictures of the one you sold. I want to purchase one that will hold its value. I’d hate to buy at 12,500 and if my children ever go to sell they’d sell at a loss
 
Posts
1,447
Likes
3,018
oh wow! any chance you’d have another at some point to sell? any pictures of the one you sold. I want to purchase one that will hold its value. I’d hate to buy at 12,500 and if my children ever go to sell they’d sell at a loss
I'm afraid it in unlikely I get one (and then choose to sell it) as I am a collector and like to keep them all! I just cycle through and sell a portion of my collection as I buy newer pieces. I do have a few other Omegas from the 1940s that I am selling that you're welcome to see but no moonphases. It will be very hard to get one of these moonphases because of their rarity - so that's why most dealers sell at a premium!
 
Posts
3,616
Likes
24,373
I want to purchase one that will hold its value. I’d hate to buy at 12,500 and if my children ever go to sell they’d sell at a loss

Welcome to the forum and good luck with your search!

But, I must say: while we all would like our watches to hold their value, watch collecting could go the way of beanie babies by the time your children inherit them. Buy watches because you like collecting, not for investment purposes.
 
Posts
24,258
Likes
54,025
The price is very high, and I wouldn't buy it. But you could also wait a LONG time to find one with an original dial for a fair price. So it depends how determined you are to buy this particular reference, and how much the money matters to you. If you are new to vintage watches, this is not the easiest starting point.
 
Posts
9
Likes
1
Welcome to the forum and good luck with your search!

But, I must say: while we all would like our watches to hold their value, watch collecting could go the way of beanie babies by the time your children inherit them. Buy watches because you like collecting, not for investment purposes.
good point. definitely wouldn’t be the main reason. it would be because I really like it. can’t say I’ve been a better looking vintage. bring on the crap from others lol..the wife would appreciate if it holds some value down the road. but not a make or break.
 
Posts
9
Likes
1
Just another time waster. 🥱

not wasting time. appreciate all the advice. attenuated to delete post entirely, but couldn't figure out how
 
Posts
34,271
Likes
38,891
not wasting time. appreciate all the advice. attenuated to delete post entirely, but couldn't figure out how
That’s some really bad form. Goodbye

edit: Also thread reverted to original content