- Posts
- 17
- Likes
- 5
Please consider donating to help offset our high running costs.
/edit: Obviously, I'm typing too slowly. Basically, what @Peemacgee is saying. 😀
---
Agreed that the Meister doesnt carry much of a premium, but I find "mediocre" to be possibly a bit harsh, no?
Dial: Seems to be in pretty nice shape, definitely original. Not sure if the small dots are residue on the dial or dust on the plexi - the pictures by @Shabbaz when he sold the watch here looked really nice.
Case: Some dings and scratches all around, but bevels/edges are well intact, medallion sharp. It's the kind of watch that I'd very happily wear and wouldnt be too worried about. It's not great, but very wearable and to my eyes also not mediocre. Original crown too.
Minute lume loss in the hour hand and some degradation on all hands, certainly highlighted by the close-up pictures. Bracelet is a nice bonus. The rotor sure shows wear, not sure if that's a prevailing issue or not, the seller will know. Regulator is a certain sign it hasn't been serviced (well) in a while. That can be taken care of, of course.
The dial is the party piece of the watch, of course. Wouldn't be easy to find another one.
Well, to my mind it takes little wear to detract from the presentation of a dress watch. The dings and scratches on this one makes me take it down a notch or two from the top tier. It is by no means worn out - "mediocre" is fairly accurate, IMO 😀
As the current owner of this watch I’ve been following the discussion with interest.
I’m just an average guy, so “mediocre” is my middlename 😁.
As a non-native English speaker I’m in a bad position to argue about semantics in the language of Shakespeare. I can follow the logic that anything between top tier and poor is by definition “mediocre”. As biased as I am I’d go for the euphemism “fair” which would still be fairly accurate imo 😉.
Thank you for your modest evaluation of your watch. Everyone has put in their opinions...and yours is maybe the most important since you have the watch in your possession and can best judge it. Some have call it "mediocre" which isn't exactly precise. If you were explaining the term "fair"...what would be the word above that and below that. Based on the photos, I like it. Is it keeping good time? If not, how much off per day would you say? Does it wind and set with a nice crispness? Thanks again for stepping forward.
I think the valuation ideas are based on a "must-sell" market so I don't agree with them, I think the MEISTER could even 2X the value (a black dial is already 2-3X - so like 6X of a regular one), assuming a collector based high demand market forms one day - I paid these imaginary values a couple of times and I only regret not paying them, watches like these really add color to a collection, otherwise it's all gray
Hard to find a non-tropical gilt dial too, I wonder if these models are more resistant to wear, all the C-Case ones I saw were either fully tropical or in the very non-appealing in between state of shedding the coating