Newbie Seeking Seamaster Restoration Advice

Posts
11
Likes
19
Hello, I’ve been eyeballing vintage Seamasters for a few months now, and was considering spending between $750-$1000 if I found the right one. Yesterday, I won a dozen antique watches bidding online for a local estate auction and paid $10 for the lot. They were described as Westclox Pocket Watches. The picture for them was low quality, but it looked like a variety of brands. I thought I’d roll the dice and hope for some treasure. When I picked them up, I’ll be damned if the third one I examined wasn’t an Omega Seamaster

It is in rather rough shape, but is working. I’m planning to replace the crystal, have it serviced, and wear it often.

I’d appreciate your thoughts on the level of restoration you would do if it was your watch? Would you have the case polished, or redialed?

Thank you kindly!

BTW, I’ve not opened the case back to examine the movement. I’m speculating that its a 491, approximately 1958. But I don’t know much about Omega’s yet. Just got into watches a year ago with a Seiko 5.
 
Posts
4,730
Likes
11,956
Case is nice, I wouldn't polish it. Needs a new crystal. Sadly the dial seems pretty far gone. You might get lucky and find a replacement. I suppose if you want to sell it, a refldial might make sense. As a collector a redial is not for me.
 
Posts
1,175
Likes
2,455
Heck if it was for $10 can't go wrong. As for the outlook I'd agree with @wagudc. The dial is very far gone and would need replacing. The service for the movement and possible needed parts will also drive up your budget as it seems there is some water intrusion evident on the dial.
 
Posts
4,730
Likes
11,956
Heck if it was for $10 can't go wrong. As for the outlook I'd agree with @wagudc. The dial is very far gone and would need replacing. The service for the movement and possible needed parts will also drive up your budget as it seems there is some water intrusion evident on the dial.

If nothing else the case has some real value.
 
Posts
395
Likes
402
Nice find!

I’ve seen on the forums some amazing cleanup jobs on dials, though this one looks pretty out there.

Crack it open and check out the reference. Provided the movement is in good shape you likely be able to find a matching dial.
 
Posts
17,768
Likes
26,945
The repainted dial has water damage…

need to see the movement before any advice can be given. The dials a write off.
Edited:
 
Posts
11
Likes
19
All, I appreciate the sage advice. I’ve decided not to polish, and to try to keep the dial original if it can be cleaned up enough to be presentable. Otherwise it will be redialed. Sending out this week for the estimate.....

Thanks again
 
Posts
21,748
Likes
49,347
I think you'd be better off selling the case and movement for parts, and using the money for something better. There's really no point in going down this rabbit hole IMO.
 
Posts
11
Likes
19
I think you'd be better off selling the case and movement for parts, and using the money for something better. There's really no point in going down this rabbit hole IMO.

You might be right. I’ll see what the estimate comes back as...
 
Posts
21,748
Likes
49,347
You might be right. I’ll see what the estimate comes back as...

For me, the re-dial estimate is irrelevant. Any money put into it is wasted. Who wants a vintage Seamaster with a crappy repainted dial? You can get a nice collectible one for well under $1k USD.
 
Posts
11
Likes
19
UPDATE: Here's what she looks like today. Complete service with new crown and crystal. I'm very pleased with how it come out.
 
Posts
297
Likes
266
Cool!!!! You rescued her from the dumpster!!! I'm sure you'll get lots of use from her.
 
Posts
16,769
Likes
47,468
UPDATE: Here's what she looks like today. Complete service with new crown and crystal. I'm very pleased with how it come out.

All I would have done and if your happy it’s a bonus.

With a stable of nice watches sometimes it’s the ones a bit rough around the edges that you enjoy. I wear this quite often as it was my first vintage watch.



It tells the time just as good as the pretty ones……
 
Posts
11
Likes
19
It's beautiful! Coming from the world of coins and vintage motorcycles, I've come to love a nice patina. And sometimes, even a nasty one 😀
Edited:
 
Posts
120
Likes
173
That’s awesome! I like the diesel punk look of a damaged dial. Also nice story behind a bargain find!
 
Posts
560
Likes
3,965
All I would have done and if your happy it’s a bonus.

With a stable of nice watches sometimes it’s the ones a bit rough around the edges that you enjoy. I wear this quite often as it was my first vintage watch.



It tells the time just as good as the pretty ones……
In which time zones😎