Community Stories

Need Help Evaluating This Ranchero

gbesq
Posts
9,170
Likes
48,389
Good day all. I am considering the purchase of this Ranchero: 1958 Omega Ranchero CK 2990 with Omega Extract – KibbleWatches I am familiar with the seller and have purchased from him before. The watch is all original other than the crystal and has been serviced. I am obtaining a movement photo. My concern is the case which has been polished. It seems like a pretty decent polish job from what I can see, but I would like the opinions of our OF Ranchero experts. I'd also appreciate any thoughts on a fair price range. I have a three day return option if I pull the trigger. Thanks.
Edited:
 
malilis
Posts
372
Likes
363
Very nice watch ! price seems steep .. but let's wait for the experts ..
 
tdn-dk
Posts
1,724
Likes
14,673
Never seen so dark brown, almost orange lumen before, but if it is proven (Geiger) as radium it is fine, I would have expected almost similar lumen on the hands, but sometimes they age different.

Crown is a never replacement.

No movement pictures so cant see the condition of it.

There is an extract, so thats fine.

It a dealer price, but the good one also go high on eBay and other auctions. I have not seen recent prices on them.

IMG_4087.JPG
Edited:
 
gbesq
Posts
9,170
Likes
48,389
tdn-dk tdn-dk
Never seen so dark brown, almost orange lumen before, but if it is proven (Geiger) as radium it is fine, I would have expected almost similar lumen on the hands, but sometimes they age different.

Crown is a never replacement.

No movement pictures so cant see the condition of it.

There is an extract, so thats fine.

It a dealer price, but the good one also go high on eBay and other auctions. I have not seen recent prices on them.

IMG_4087.JPG
Thanks. The lume is radium and the dial and hands are original. I was aware that the crown is a newer replacement, but it is period correct so not a big deal. The seller has lowered the price to a point that I consider acceptable and will throw in free international shipping via DHL and full insurance. I would have three days to inspect and initiate a return of the watch after receiving it with no questions asked. I have done business with the seller before and was very happy with what I received, so I'm inclined to do business with him again unless someone sees something glaring on the watch that I'm not noticing.
 
studeb
Posts
356
Likes
446
Can’t figure out the clouds on the dial. They are in some pics, others not. Not sure if it’s dust on the crystal or something else.
 
gemini4
Posts
5,859
Likes
16,772
Have to disagree with the OP regarding “decent polish job”.
 
gbesq
Posts
9,170
Likes
48,389
gemini4 gemini4
Have to disagree with the OP regarding “decent polish job”.
Perhaps so, but given that I can return the watch no questions asked within 3 days of receiving it for a full refund, do you really see a downside? I have any number of watches in my collection that arrived looking far better in the flesh than they appeared in their sale listing photos.
 
gemini4
Posts
5,859
Likes
16,772
gbesq gbesq
Perhaps so, but given that I can return the watch no questions asked within 3 days of receiving it for a full refund, do you really see a downside? I have any number of watches in my collection that arrived looking far better in the flesh than they appeared in their sale listing photos.

You are absolutely correct. As an owner of a few Rancheros, I was just expressing my opinion.
Perhaps post a few pics of the watch in question. The link to the listing won’t last forever.
 
gbesq
Posts
9,170
Likes
48,389
gemini4 gemini4
You are absolutely correct. As an owner of a few Rancheros, I was just expressing my opinion.
Perhaps post a few pics of the watch in question. The link to the listing won’t last forever.
I'll PM you.
 
eugeneandresson
Posts
5,048
Likes
15,518
For posterity, posting pictures from links that will go dead in the near future is a great adderf of value to this forum 👍
 
gbesq
Posts
9,170
Likes
48,389
eugeneandresson eugeneandresson
For posterity, posting pictures from links that will go dead in the near future is a great adderf of value to this forum 👍
Duly noted. Apologies.
 
Sign up or log in to reply...

Similar threads

drpaul

Want help evaluating 18k seamaster

drpaul Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
drpaul
drpaul
Posts
7
Views
2K
drpaul

Help evaluating ebay offer SOLID 18K ROSE GOLD - REF. 14707

drpaul Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
michael e
michael e
Posts
6
Views
2K
318aye

Newer Collector in need of help! (Evaluation of Cosmic TDMP & Seamaster 120 / 600)

318aye Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
318aye
318aye
Posts
17
Views
3K
A

Need help evaluating Omega DeVille Prestige gold

Alex_bon Modern Omega Watches
tyrantlizardrex
tyrantlizardrex
Posts
5
Views
3K
R

Need help evaluating this watch

Rmanz Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
R
Rmanz
Posts
6
Views
1K
Thommas

Help evaluating a Speedmaster 105.012-65

Thommas Vintage Omega Watches Help, Discussion and Advice
Screwbacks
Screwbacks
Posts
8
Views
1K