Please consider donating to help offset our high running costs.
Between the two, I would choose the first one, because on the wrist the dial probably looks ok. This second dial is not appealing to me. Of course, I wouldn't pay $1500, and if selling it, I would certainly price it below $1k.
... if you tell me where I can find 14393s in good condition for under $1,000 USD, I'll go right away.