I Need To Buy One... Please Help Me

Posts
1,933
Likes
8,481
Since both are gorgeous and have compelling reasons to buy, I present my case before you; which of these will represent Cartier better for posterity, in class and in beauty?
I can buy only one!!
Regards
(Images from internet)
 
Posts
1,933
Likes
8,481
Both? Neither? They're the same, only different. Pick what you like.
Please don't add misery to the confusion, what will you take and why. That will help me. Regards
 
Posts
5,636
Likes
5,811
Please don't add misery to the confusion, what will you take and why. That will help me. Regards
Neither, to be honest. Not my style. Plus I much prefer a bracelet.
 
Posts
701
Likes
2,445
I like the blue/black one better. I also think it will match better with a varied wardrobe. I find brown only goes well with brown/beige outfits. The dark one is more flexible
 
Posts
1,933
Likes
8,481
Neither, to be honest. Not my style. Plus I much prefer a bracelet.
That's an honest reply sir. Thanks indeed. Regards
 
Posts
1,245
Likes
4,778
Is the brown dial really brown or a bit toward red as I view it? Given brown, I would go with the other for the above reasons. If the dial goes toward red I might feel otherwise. But even so, the blue/black is a better representation for posterity. I think. Lovely dilemma you find yourself in.

have fun
kfw
 
Posts
24,372
Likes
54,232
If you are concerned about representing Cartier for posterity, you should probably stick with the classic white dial tank. Both of these, while attractive, are a bit gimmicky IMO.
 
Posts
1,789
Likes
9,100
Blue is sporty, brown more elegant; I say brown 😉
 
Posts
13,719
Likes
53,542
Neither. Too fussy for my taste.
 
Posts
1,933
Likes
8,481
Is the brown dial really brown or a bit toward red as I view it? Given brown, I would go with the other for the above reasons. If the dial goes toward red I might feel otherwise. But even so, the blue/black is a better representation for posterity. I think. Lovely dilemma you find yourself in.

have fun
kfw
It's red, rather burgundy dial and similar on the leather strap. The other is blue gray on dial with blue leather strap.
 
Posts
1,485
Likes
8,119
Blue/gray.
Goes with everything.

Red dial is too “specific” for me. Don’t see myself picking it from the box often.
Xmas, Valentine…bdays and anniversaries.

dare I say blue jeans and t-shirt? Works for me.
Edited:
 
Posts
56
Likes
215
let it pass,if after 2 months you still have the same love for them then go blue.
 
Posts
18,211
Likes
27,546
Of the 2 the RG in blue.

honestly you should get a reverso.
 
Posts
4,593
Likes
10,810
If you are concerned about representing Cartier for posterity, you should probably stick with the classic white dial tank. Both of these, while attractive, are a bit gimmicky IMO.

True that. Those dials pictured remind me of the cheaper and more recent "Must De Cartier" models.
 
Posts
1,933
Likes
8,481
Of the 2 the RG in blue.

honestly you should get a reverso.
I do have TT 1931 Reverso sir, and it's a great watch..
These Tank watches, though unusual somewhat, look to be good novelty from Cartier.