Help with 166.024 Seamaster

Posts
33
Likes
12
Hey all,

Looking into this 166.024 I came across. Not a good enough expert to know if it's genuine, or at least genuine with relumed parts. Comes on a 1039/516 bracelet.

Thanks in advance!

 
Posts
8,514
Likes
60,867
Please outline your research with pictures and add an explanation of your conclusions.

Education is a big part of our Forum and I need some 300 education.
 
Posts
33
Likes
12
Things specifically that make me question the authenticity or at least if everything's original:
-There's a clear pin dot in the 6 marker, but I don't see one at the 12 (and I thought there was always either both present or neither, but never just 1? Would love an actual expert to chime in)
-Caseback looks too...good? Lasered? But it also doesn't look like a 166.0324 caseback (which doesn't have the long top A that this one has). I've also never seen a confirmed fake caseback with the long flat-top A in 'waterproof', they're always narrow
-Otherwise, everything lines up (seems to be a ~1969, which makes sense with the 516/1039 bracelet with 69 date code; screw down crown; BT with sword hands, etc.)

I think getting it and opening up the caseback and getting an idea of the movement and case/caseback will be helpful, but I will probably have to buy it to do that (at least they offer returns). It's being sold by an antique store that doesn't usually carry watches.
Edited:
 
Posts
2,643
Likes
3,096
Whenever I see vintage knick knacks as sellers other items I immediately trust the item, but that's my flaw
 
Posts
33
Likes
12
My doubt isn't the seller doing it on purpose, but probably has no idea about anything and might have bought it from someone less scrupulous and is re-selling it not knowing if it has issues.

Ended up buying it, should arrive next week. When it arrives I’ll pop off the caseback and take some pics to add. Would still love the experts opinions based on the above though.
 
Posts
2,316
Likes
5,703
My doubt isn't the seller doing it on purpose, but probably has no idea about anything and might have bought it from someone less scrupulous and is re-selling it not knowing if it has issues.

Ended up buying it, should arrive next week. When it arrives I’ll pop off the caseback and take some pics to add. Would still love the experts opinions based on the above though.

Ha! 2nd highest bidder here. Nice to meet you! 😉
I've been eyeing this one since it popped up last week.
It's one of the nicest ones to surface in the past year+ I would say.
It's original down to the spring bars...
You did good.
Edited:
 
Posts
1,104
Likes
1,706
Whenever I see vintage knick knacks as sellers other items I immediately trust the item, but that's my flaw
👍
 
Posts
1,570
Likes
2,681
My doubt isn't the seller doing it on purpose, but probably has no idea about anything and might have bought it from someone less scrupulous and is re-selling it not knowing if it has issues.

Ended up buying it, should arrive next week. When it arrives I’ll pop off the caseback and take some pics to add. Would still love the experts opinions based on the above though.
I was wondering who else had their eye on this piece. Good to see that it's in the OF family.
 
Posts
975
Likes
1,516
What IS the deal with that case back, though? The hands also look like replacements, no?
 
Posts
13,211
Likes
22,975
What’s wrong with the caseback? Looks fine to me
 
Posts
975
Likes
1,516
It looks strangely “fresh” and like it was ground down and re-engraved or something. Maybe I am seeing it wrong….
 
Posts
33
Likes
12
What IS the deal with that case back, though? The hands also look like replacements, no?
I don’t see any issues with the hands. The only comment is the lume color shade is different than the dial, but it’s pretty common for hand lume to patina at a different rate than dial like.
Caseback just looks brand new, but it could have been worn minimally. At least to my eyes.
Edited:
 
Posts
975
Likes
1,516
I’m sure your right. In one shot the hands looked too “shiny” to be original lume, but I am also looking on my phone, so…
 
Posts
5,636
Likes
5,811
What’s wrong with the caseback? Looks fine to me
The lettering was done by laser. It should be stamped.
 
Posts
5,636
Likes
5,811
Not acid etched?
Nope. Laser is very easy to see, because it's a pulse, not continuous, so it's a series of circles, and the precision is not great, because you have to move the laser head or the work piece, so the lines wobble a bit. This one is so clearly laser it's not worth considering anything else.

Omega, on the other hand, stamps these casebacks, and then grinds down the metal that is pushed up in the stamping process. Whether it is a flat stamp or a rolling stamp, can't tell and doesn't matter. It impresses the metal and what gets pushed up is ground down so you get the result you see on a real caseback.
 
Posts
5,636
Likes
5,811
Here is a reproduction by Colt of the pistol they produced for and during WWI. It is roll-marked but it was wartime, so they skipped the "grind it flat" step. You can (hopefully) see little ridges outlining the letters.
 
Posts
33
Likes
12
Nope. Laser is very easy to see, because it's a pulse, not continuous, so it's a series of circles, and the precision is not great, because you have to move the laser head or the work piece, so the lines wobble a bit. This one is so clearly laser it's not worth considering anything else.

Omega, on the other hand, stamps these casebacks, and then grinds down the metal that is pushed up in the stamping process. Whether it is a flat stamp or a rolling stamp, can't tell and doesn't matter. It impresses the metal and what gets pushed up is ground down so you get the result you see on a real caseback.
So what's the deal with it then? It won't arrive for a couple weeks because of eBay's authentication service (and after that, there's still a 2 week return window).

I agree that it looks lasered or at least not-stamped. Looking online, it actually does look like a variant of a 166.0324 service caseback.

And if it's a 166.0324 service caseback, I don't particularly mind, but -- should I worry about the case itself potentially being service and not original, as well?
 
This website may earn commission from Ebay sales.
Posts
8,514
Likes
60,867
Lots to worry about, did you ever see the movement?