Experience matters, but “stamped means regret” does not survive the catalogue. Plenty of high-end dials are printed by choice: Cartier Tank, Lange 1815, IWC Mark 11. No one calls them low budget.
Applied is not always sharper. You still see misaligned feet, soft plating, tarnish, and sloppy refits. Photos hide sins on both sides.
Depth is a technique, not a virtue. Judge layout, proportion, and condition, not relief height. Some design languages are more realistically done with print or embossing; hairline, Bauhaus-style numerals are rarely feasible as applied without thickening the strokes.
And with experience, some of us start to prize method over outcome. It is easy to nit-pick what is “considered best” and lose sight of the basics: balance, legibility, and coherence.