Fitting Elma Style Baskets to an L&R Cleaning Machine

Posts
2,358
Likes
2,539
As many of you know, I've done a lot of work on my L&R Console cleaning machine. I've now been using it ~6 months, and have hit a point of annoyance: Baskets.

I invested a few hundred bucks in baskets of both sizes a while back, so I have a decent number. However, I kind of hate the L&R baskets.

Large ones:
The large one is 3 tiers with a bunch of little baskets. Admittedly, the ones I have aren't in the best shape, but I never feel like things are separated securely. Also, getting to the 'lower' baskets requires pulling out the upper basket in a way that is at high risk of spilling stuff.

Small ones:
The small ones are kinda neat with the top piece, and I have the little insert in the bottom that has a lid. However, I find that this ends up being too small/not having enough compartments when I really want them, so I end up having to do most watches I work on in 2 different runs.

At one point, i picked up THIS style of basket/complete set, available for ~$60 on ebay.



However, I found that while the baskets were fine, the part the connected to the machine was pot-metal cast aluminum. It wasn't even close to 'round' or concentric in any way, and attempts to drill out the center hole to make it work with the 9.5mm hole on the machine exposed how brittle the metal was/how poorly made it all was.


RECENTLY, I discovered this on AliX: https://www.aliexpress.us/item/3256810257154917.html?
It is sold as an ELMA basket, and has the complete set including the top with the 'spring' on it. They ARE expensive at ~$200 for the full set though, so not for the feint of heart! I will say though, I spent more putting together a decent set of L&R baskets, so it is competitive.



As you can see, the top of the basket has a half-decent steel ring. HOWEVER, the hole in the ring is 8mm, instead of 9.5mm (or 3/8"?) on the L&R machine.

I ordered it a while back, and got it in while I was away on my trip! I decided to work on it today. I chucked just the top plastic up in my 6 jaw (like a 3 jaw, only... 2x) on my metal working lathe. I avoided getting the 'nubs' interfering with the vice jaws, and did a little bit of boring on it with a boring bar. I was REALLY shocked to see how little runout it had! The plastic is pretty darn stout, so you can crank down on it reasonably hard, and the metal ring ran pretty concentrically.

After taking off the 1.5mm, and adding a M4x0.7mm set screw, it mounted to my machine perfectly:



I ran it through the rinse in a cycle, and it seemed to work perfectly! The baskets have quite a bit of variety, so hopefully I can do the amount of organization I want without risking losing pieces! AND, it is a bit futureproof.

So an idea for anyone who has an L&R and is unhappy with the baskets, for ~$200 and a 20 minute lathe adventure (plus a 25c set screw!) you too could have Elma style baskets!
 
Posts
101
Likes
120
I have an Elma RM90 that I was lucky enough to pick up for much less than they usually go for, and baskets and cages are the bane of my life as far as that machine is concerned. I've tried a couple of the Chinese ones but they just don't fit properly, which is a shame as they are much more reasonably priced. So in the end it was a visit to the Cousins website and springing for the real McCoy. Looks like the ones you have bought are good quality though!
 
Posts
18,411
Likes
38,337
I've tried a couple of the Chinese ones but they just don't fit properly,
When I splashed out and bought my Elma Solvex SE I found that the basket refused to attach to the mount. I contacted the seller and they sent me a replacement (exchange) set and it was a perfect fit, so even Elma "out of the box" components aren't problem free.
 
Posts
147
Likes
123
I have bought an Elma Super Elite that is missing the basket, but does have the circular mounting bracket.

So I am weighing up whether to buy this or pay the extra to get it from Cousins, minus the bracket.

How has the Ali version held up? Are the divider joints glued or soldered in place? I was also looking at buying the baskets and frame separately on Ali, but I read one review that said the joints dissolve in IPA…
 
Posts
2,358
Likes
2,539
The set I got is holding up fine. The joints are all soldered.

I will note they are inconsistent in height. I bought JUST baskets to have spares, and they are too tall to go into my blue holder. I'll have to turn them down at one point, but I'm not sure I would buy anything but a full set again.
 
Posts
147
Likes
123
The set I got is holding up fine. The joints are all soldered.

I will note they are inconsistent in height. I bought JUST baskets to have spares, and they are too tall to go into my blue holder. I'll have to turn them down at one point, but I'm not sure I would buy anything but a full set again.

Great thanks. It is always good to get a first hand review of something on Ali as you can never be quite sure!

Are you able to insert it fully into the drier without worrying about it melting?
 
Posts
2,358
Likes
2,539
Great thanks. It is always good to get a first hand review of something on Ali as you can never be quite sure!

Are you able to insert it fully into the drier without worrying about it melting?
Yep, no problems there. It's been thru my console machine about a dozen times now, which gets quite hot. It's pretty good quality plastic best I can tell.
 
Posts
147
Likes
123
Yep, no problems there. It's been thru my console machine about a dozen times now, which gets quite hot. It's pretty good quality plastic best I can tell.

Perfect. Well I have ordered one so you should get a commission from Ali! Just need to find a lid for the heater compartment as that was also missing, but not a big deal I guess.

What did you find most effective for cleaning the dirt out of the inside of the jars? IPA?
 
Posts
2,358
Likes
2,539
I never really had a problem with just soap and water and a sponge, but they don't really get that dirty.
 
Posts
18,411
Likes
38,337
The set I got is holding up fine. The joints are all soldered.

I will note they are inconsistent in height. I bought JUST baskets to have spares, and they are too tall to go into my blue holder. I'll have to turn them down at one point, but I'm not sure I would buy anything but a full set again.
Rather than turn them down, can you print a basket?
@GuiltyGear has designed a 3d print model that suits the Elma style wire baskets.
I'll post some pics in the morning, I'm off ot bed now.
 
Posts
2,358
Likes
2,539
Rather than turn them down, can you print a basket?
@GuiltyGear has designed a 3d print model that suits the Elma style wire baskets.
I'll post some pics in the morning, I'm off ot bed now.
Maybe? But having the two sets not be compatible despite being otherwise identical is still problematic.

Also, only have a resin printer 😀
 
Posts
710
Likes
2,074
This guy?

Not sure how it will print in resin, never bothered with it. But as an enthusiast, maybe time to invest in an FDM printer?
 
Posts
18,411
Likes
38,337
This guy?
Excellent, saved me from having to get off my butt and actually do something.
😁
 
Posts
3
Likes
2
I've always thought the Elma-style baskets had a much more practical layout, especially when you're working on multiple watches or trying to keep parts organized by assembly. The L&R baskets get the job done, but they're definitely not the most convenient design.
If you end up making the Elma set fit the L&R machine, I'd be interested in seeing what modifications were needed. I imagine there are quite a few people with older L&R machines who would appreciate a cleaner basket solution.
 
Posts
2,358
Likes
2,539
I've always thought the Elma-style baskets had a much more practical layout, especially when you're working on multiple watches or trying to keep parts organized by assembly. The L&R baskets get the job done, but they're definitely not the most convenient design.
If you end up making the Elma set fit the L&R machine, I'd be interested in seeing what modifications were needed. I imagine there are quite a few people with older L&R machines who would appreciate a cleaner basket solution.
You'll see I was able to make it work on my L&R console above. I picked up the $200 full set off aliX and just had to modify the hole on the basket holder.

It took about 10 minutes in my lathe. I probably wouldn't do it without at least a drill press (and if so, you would need a reamer and undersized drill bit) as the fit on shaft is pretty important.