Fake Daytona Sh*tstorm

Posts
839
Likes
3,026
here is the link to the thread on detecting fake guarantee cards

https://www.rolexforums.com/showthread.php?t=716674

i just looked at both of mine and appear authentic. . .to be honest these super fakes are just too hard for even experienced watch people to figure it out

It's tough, especially on the Rolex. Best way is to loop the movement. It will look poorly finished on the fake. Watch this starting at about 4:30.

 
Posts
1,372
Likes
2,000
And thank you Connieseamaster, (from below) if that IS your real name, for the kind words. Were you a card collector? Stingray rider?

It's my real avatar, anyways 馃榿. I tried to be a Beanie Baby collector, but my father's lectures about manufactured collectability and how toys are meant to be played with ran too deep.
 
Posts
3,998
Likes
9,018
And I see comments about Rolex creating a new way of securing their watches, but my real problem is in that watches that are ALMOST exactly the same can be made for pennies on the dollar. I will never again be able to pay thousands for a new luxury watch. The world has changed. And I get Rolex makes a very nice watch. My Sub is still one of a few favorites and will remain so. At some point we have to ask what we are paying for , I guess.

This idea I don't get. Search google for watchmakers showing the performance differences of, e.g., a Rolex vs even the absolute best clones. A brand new clone can't hold a performance candle to a 25 year old Rolex.

Now, you may say, "but is performance/quality of build really THAT important compared to price?" But then you'd be making the case for simply purchasing quartz watches, not clones...
 
Posts
56
Likes
27
This is absolutely crazy. I follow Horology House on IG and have seen a few of his videos on YouTube. He had a ton of followers and has been around for quite awhile.

A lot of his videos were comparing replicas to originals and how to spot the differences.

I would have felt pretty comfortable buying the seller had I been buying from him. This doesn鈥檛 sound like a mistake but sounds like he was blatantly trying to con the buyer. Absolutely insane.
Agree Likewise. When you look at his reputation & online image etc. it makes for a compelling story of trust.
 
Posts
13,310
Likes
18,424
I wonder if Rolex could embed a small chip in the watch, similar to when you chip a pet.
That would work for about five minutes.

You underestimate the will of these counterfeiters.
gatorcpa
 
Posts
95
Likes
395
Between the fakes and Rolex's own market manipulation, I wouldn't dream of touching the brand right now. I know that they fake Omegas and JLCs and everything else too, but I also know that I can walk into an Omega boutique and get almost any watch offered at MSRP and walk out knowing that I have the real thing on my wrist.
 
Posts
907
Likes
1,294
It's tough, especially on the Rolex. Best way is to loop the movement. It will look poorly finished on the fake. Watch this starting at about 4:30.

There are a lot of things that seprate the good one from the fake without opening the back (the red Daytona on the dial is the first and probably best inidication). BUT, one need to know where and what to look for.
As someone said here " if it is not perfect, it's not a real Rolex"
 
Posts
5,071
Likes
15,650
Wouldn't it be nice if the watch manufacturers could somehow apply/inbed something on the actual watch that the crooks cannot replicate. If I were Rolex I would be all over this.


Rolex has tried. Its just easier than ever to copy designs and program machine tools.

Actually Bucherer (if memory serves...there was lots of bubbly involved) has a neat authentication trick they showed us at Baselworld last year I am not certain will be easy to reverse engineer. Shine a laser (ie laser pointer) on a certain spot on the dial from a certain distance at a certain angle, and it reflects the laser in such a way as to produce a clear water-mark like pattern on the reflected laser on the surface/wall behind. Simple yet effective. Have different patterns per model per year etc...
 
Posts
610
Likes
3,834
How did Bernie Madoff, Allen Stanford, Jeff Skilling and many others get away with multi billion dollar frauds? They were con men who had the talent to deceive and still have people believe in them. HH was a peanut in the scam world, but hits close to home because of the watch angle.

I wouldn't freak out about buying a Rolex watch from established grey market dealers, you will almost always get the real deal. But only work with established dealers who have the watch in hand, can send you detailed pics of the watch, details of the warranty card, provide references, etc In the Essery case this didn't happen and the buyer relied on his reputation.on Youtube and social media, which tell you nothing about his financial history and trustworthiness. If the buyer had asked for references up front I suspect the deal would have collapsed.

Yes but selling replica watches and trying to pass off as authentic seems like a short sighted ponzi scheme that wouldn't last very long. After reading this is more detail though, I think this may have been the first outright fake but I guess that's TBD. From all the other incidents reported so far he would do the deal and then delay delay delay (shipping probs, customs. etc.) and then return the funds after months of back and forth and no watch.
 
Posts
29,672
Likes
76,830
As someone said here " if it is not perfect, it's not a real Rolex"

Hmmm....that doesn't always ring true...this is a real Rolex, and it's not exactly "perfect"...



馃槈
 
Posts
610
Likes
3,834
There are a lot of things that seprate the good one from the fake without opening the back (the red Daytona on the dial is the first and probably best inidication). BUT, one need to know where and what to look for.
As someone said here " if it is not perfect, it's not a real Rolex"

Not exactly true. With enough magnification you can start to see flaws. Ironically enough, I believe Horology House did many of these types of macro vids. Even Patek starts showing flaws at a certain point. A lot of this stuff is done/applied by hand after all.
 
Posts
104
Likes
112
Considering all the stages this watch went through
No one noticed or saw this blinding error at Rolex Quality Control
Must have been their day off....or they need to go to spec savers.馃檨..
 
Posts
303
Likes
308
Hmmm....that doesn't always ring true...this is a real Rolex, and it's not exactly "perfect"...



馃槈
Does that make it right four times per day 馃槈
 
Posts
8,097
Likes
28,527
Considering all the stages this watch went through
No one noticed or saw this blinding error at Rolex Quality Control
Must have been their day off....or they need to go to spec savers.馃檨..

There was a time, as older members may recall, when some astute American car buyers would refine what they wanted, and insist on examples that were produced Tuesday, Wednesday or Thursday. The angle, which apparently had merit, was that the regular workers might call in sick on Mondays or Fridays in order to enjoy three day weekends, leaving less experienced line workers to fill in.
 
Posts
1,438
Likes
2,213
My absolute favorite comment from the fauxlex scandal on the Rolex snob site.

Yeah, that was classic TRF. Spare no opportunity to disparage a rival brand, even in a thread ostensibly devoted to winnowing out a FraudLex. Because, ya know, it's a kind of feather in the cap of a brand that fakers will spend so much time and effort and money to build those fakes, and that glory must therefore reflect brightly onto you, the canny and accomplished owner of the real thing. Or are you? Aren't you? Zounds!

Another and more positive takeaway, of course, is that enthusiast communities are a crucial bulwark against this level of fakery, which is great, so long as that isn't a full-time job, I suppose. Anyhoo, refocusing on ADs and trusted sellers is looking more and more like the way to go -- especially if you're not holding out for an SS sports/pro Rolex.
 
Posts
1,819
Likes
5,923
Another and more positive takeaway, of course, is that enthusiast communities are a crucial bulwark against this level of fakery, which is great, so long as that isn't a full-time job, I suppose.

Yeah but in this case the scammer was a prominent guy among several enthusiast communities....either as an admin or mod on the FB groups, or the guy running his own site as well as his YT and IG pages with tens of thousands of followers. And he was protected by other admins/mods on those sites.

I'm less alarmed by the quality of the fake, or the fact that there are scammers among us. That's always been the case in this hobby and why people need to do real research into what they're buying and use trusted sources.

It's the fact that these enthusiast communities were completely compromised. To some degree they were either founded or moderated by this guy and ended up being a bulwark against honesty and transparency. That is what separates this scandal from the many other watch scams I've seen reported over the years.
 
Posts
315
Likes
781
Hmmm....that doesn't always ring true...this is a real Rolex, and it's not exactly "perfect"...



馃槈
Probably tripled the value 馃榾
 
Posts
13,698
Likes
53,498
Probably tripled the value 馃榾
I believe that may be an understatement. 馃榿
 
Posts
13,698
Likes
53,498
There was a time, as older members may recall, when some astute American car buyers would refine what they wanted, and insist on examples that were produced Tuesday, Wednesday or Thursday. The angle, which apparently had merit, was that the regular workers might call in sick on Mondays or Fridays in order to enjoy three day weekends, leaving less experienced line workers to fill in.
Yeah ...You just made me feel old...Thanks Tony::facepalm1::