Caseback reworked with a Dremel?

Posts
206
Likes
163
On an otherwise OK 145.022 I saw this caseback that looks to me as if a previous owner has tried to "refresh" the engraving. (he forgot four circles though)
Does anyone have a better explanation than Dremel?

 
Posts
28,018
Likes
71,483
Looks like chatter from working it on a lathe to me, rather than something done with a Dremel.
 
Posts
2,443
Likes
4,229
Looks like chatter from working it on a lathe to me, rather than something done with a Dremel.
There was probably a lathe involved initially, but I think OP is talking about someone using a Dremel like an engraver to "redraw" the hippocampus with deeper lines. I don't think they forgot the circles, I think the tip of the engraver was just too large.
 
Posts
342
Likes
342
It’s unfortunate that people try to “revive” pieces without knowledge or experience, or better yet, don’t know to leave well enough alone
 
Posts
147
Likes
118
It was turned on a lathe with a dull cutting tool or the wrong speed.
 
Posts
28,018
Likes
71,483
It was turned on a lathe with a dull cutting tool or the wrong speed.

Yes, that’s definitely how you get chatter...
 
Posts
206
Likes
163
OP is talking about someone using a Dremel like an engraver to "redraw" the hippocampus
As a matter of fact that's what I meant. I didn't even notice the chatter @Archer mentioned.Shame on me.
I wonder how much of the original thickness of the back is left.

By the way, the three small circles in the red area survived. Those in the blue area didn't make it.



Anyway, I'll let this one pass.
Edited: