Black dial Constellation 14393 - Buy or not ?

Posts
50
Likes
85
Hi! I found this black piepan dial on ebay and about to buy it but just want to make sure if this is look good on you guys... Most importantly, dial looks original to me but is it common that the colors of dial ( gold ) and case ( stainless silver ) are different like that ? Thanks !
 
Posts
2,762
Likes
6,843
Yes that is ok. My bigger concern is whether the dial furniture which appears to be rose gold matches with the case back which is yellow gold. Normally these will be aligned. It’s possible that the yellow gold dial furniture has developed some patina to appear rose gold, or that the case back has been swapped.

I’ve been watching this one as well, curious to hear what others think.
 
Posts
50
Likes
85
Yes that is ok. My bigger concern is whether the dial furniture which appears to be rose gold matches with the case back which is yellow gold. Normally these will be aligned. It’s possible that the yellow gold dial furniture has developed some patina to appear rose gold, or that the case back has been swapped.

I’ve been watching this one as well, curious to hear what others think.
I asked the seller and seller said the dial markers were probably yellow gold when new, and as it ages with oxidation it appears to be more rose gold than yellow gold as we see now..
 
Posts
1,518
Likes
1,655
Yes that is ok. My bigger concern is whether the dial furniture which appears to be rose gold matches with the case back which is yellow gold. Normally these will be aligned. It’s possible that the yellow gold dial furniture has developed some patina to appear rose gold, or that the case back has been swapped.

I’ve been watching this one as well, curious to hear what others think.
I have some 50s yg case that turned in to some redish gold, so that might be the case here
 
Posts
1,078
Likes
1,630
Some of the minute markers look at bit wonky. Especially those above 4 and 8 o'clock.
 
Posts
5,082
Likes
15,689
Is it weird for the date window to be a different gold than the rest of the dial?
 
Posts
50
Likes
85
Some of the minute markers look at bit wonky. Especially those above 4 and 8 o'clock.
Do u think it’s a redial?
 
Posts
50
Likes
85
Is it weird for the date window to be a different gold than the rest of the dial?
It could be date window is a original color but less oxidyized ??
 
Posts
7,807
Likes
35,450
Nothing to worry about, I have a similar 14381 which also has more reddish looking hands/markers/gilt when compared to the medallion.

 
Posts
50
Likes
85
Nothing to worry about, I have a similar 14381 which also has more reddish looking hands/markers/gilt when compared to the medallion.

Now i'm worrying about the wondy dials like arturo7 said... 🤔
 
Posts
308
Likes
963
Depends how OCD you are, that misaligned star would drive me crazy 🤨 😁
 
Posts
50
Likes
85
Depends how OCD you are, that misaligned star would drive me crazy 🤨 😁
I didn’t even notice about the star... Good point!
 
Posts
6,074
Likes
9,409
I didn’t even notice about the star... Good point!

I don't think it is a good point
it looks fine to me
like @watchyouwant I think its just the angle of the photograph

any other photo angles to assess the 4 & 5 indices better?
 
Posts
50
Likes
85
I don't think it is a good point
it looks fine to me
like @watchyouwant I think its just the angle of the photograph

any other photo angles to assess the 4 & 5 indices better?
Sorry im such a newbie haha .. Unfortunateley, that’s all the seller uploaded.. I’ll ask about it because i also wonder about it! Do u believe its an original dial?
 
Posts
308
Likes
963
I don't think, it's misaligned. It's the angle of the photo.
You could well be right but I’d want to check that though 😉
 
Posts
6,074
Likes
9,409
Do u believe its an original dial?

looks good to me
correct font
correct placement of the vertical cross hair in relation to 'Constellation'
(and if it hadn't been, members like @cristos71 and @watchyouwant would have said so)

for what it is worth - I think the 'misaligned' 4 & 5 indices is just the angle of the photo too
 
Posts
308
Likes
963
I don't think it is a good point
it looks fine to me
like @watchyouwant I think its just the angle of the photograph

any other photo angles to assess the 4 & 5 indices better?
As already mentioned it may just be the angle of the photo but to say “I don’t think it is a good point” or it’s not worth pointing out, I disagree.
If the potential buyer is now aware of this he can clarify with the seller before purchase
 
Posts
6,074
Likes
9,409
As already mentioned it may just be the angle of the photo but to say “I don’t think it is a good point” or it’s not worth pointing out, I disagree.
If the potential buyer is now aware of this he can clarify with the seller before purchase

I’ve no desire to get into a pissing match about something so inconsequential but pointing out a potential issue is different to being unequivocal, as you were, to a self-proclaimed noob who appeared to accept your comment as gospel.

I may have been a little blunt in my condemnation of the comment but it was more about the reaction of the OP and to highlight to them to not accept everything they’re told at face value.
 
Posts
308
Likes
963
I’ve no desire to get into a pissing match about something so inconsequential but pointing out a potential issue is different to being unequivocal, as you were, to a self-proclaimed noob who appeared to accept your comment as gospel.

I may have been a little blunt in my condemnation of the comment but it was more about the reaction of the OP and to highlight to them to not accept everything they’re told at face value.
Absolutely