Community Stories

Aristocracy of Taste v/s Democracy of Acquisitions (Reflections)

krogerfoot
Posts
1,068
Likes
3,703
Archer Archer
I'm not sure why, but you seem to want to take every sentence I write, and make it the most extreme representation of something that it can be. Of course doing this is your choice, and in the end it doesn't matter to me, but if you are trying to understand my opinions as you claim, I don't think this is the way to do it.

I really am not looking for a fight, and I think there is a lot of lovely insight in your example about the Group of Seven, among others. I do want to point out, however, that everything in the post you quoted is in fact drawn nearly word for word from your posts in this thread.

But I don't think you're obligated to be interrogated about every comment you've made here. I do apologize if I'm hectoring you, and I find your views to be thoughtful and well-considered.
 
Archer
Posts
27,359
Likes
69,758
krogerfoot krogerfoot
I really am not looking for a fight, and I think there is a lot of lovely insight in your example about the Group of Seven, among others. I do want to point out, however, that everything in the post you quoted is in fact drawn nearly word for word from your posts in this thread.

But I don't think you're obligated to be interrogated about every comment you've made here. I do apologize if I'm hectoring you, and I find your views to be thoughtful and well-considered.

Thanks. Keep in mind that although I wrote those words (didn't deny it, by the way) that taking them in the extreme as the sum of my position is the issue. There is clearly a lot to unpack in this discussion, so defining my position as completely one thing or another does not reflect the reality of what I'm saying as a whole.

Cheers, Al
 
Peemacgee
Posts
5,460
Likes
8,495
krogerfoot krogerfoot
Rubens is useful as a way of illustrating how fashions and standards of female beauty have shifted back and forth over the centuries. But His fame does not rest on his having painted the pretty ladies of his day. We keep invoking a painter whose reputation has endured for 400 years and gliding right past this very salient point.

I agree that there are Old Masters who have been appreciated for centuries and remain so today.
Are Ruben's paintings historically important? yes
Are they skilfully painted? Yes
Are they skilfully composed? yes

None of this leads necessarily to an attribution of intrinsic beauty -only enduring appreciation of a master painter of his time.
 
Tony C.
Posts
7,643
Likes
26,498
Peemacgee Peemacgee
As I noted previously, this is not a nil-sum game.
No-one is undercutting anyone else, that's my point.

We agree on that point, but view it from different perspectives. I would argue that it is possible for there to be intrinsic beauty, yet humans are free to react to it any way that they like. Some people choose not to engage in sex, which is certainly a more profound drive than that to appreciate even the most obvious sort of beauty.

Peemacgee Peemacgee
Now you have set a quality judgment on the viewer (or listener)
"humans who have an appreciation either for nature, or classical music"
does this exclude those who do not have a self-professed appreciation or is this in fact the crux of the matter?

No one need be excluded, and certainly from the nature example. But classical music can be an acquired taste, and its beauty less obvious to at least some of those who have not previously had much (or any) exposure to it.

Peemacgee Peemacgee
However, I don't believe mass-confirmation of anything bestows an intrinsic value, simply a mass-appreciation

No, I wouldn't say that it bestows anything, but would argue that it can reflect intrinsic value.
 
krogerfoot
Posts
1,068
Likes
3,703
Peemacgee Peemacgee
I agree that there are Old Masters who have been appreciated for centuries and remain so today.
Are Ruben's paintings historically important? yes
Are they skilfully painted? Yes
Are they skilfully composed? yes

None of this leads necessarily to an attribution of intrinsic beauty -only enduring appreciation of a master painter of his time.

This is probably only understandable to North Americans of a certain CRS-susceptible age, but: "Hey, you got your attribution of intrinsic beauty in my enduring appreciation of a master painter!" "No, YOU got YOUR enduring appreciation of a master painter in MY attribution of intrinsic beauty!"

 
Peemacgee
Posts
5,460
Likes
8,495
Tony C. Tony C.
No, I wouldn't say that it bestows anything, but would argue that it can reflect intrinsic value.

In the spirit of @krogerfoot 's peanut butter cups, I'll concede that it might reflect a perceived intrinsic value 😉
 
Archer
Posts
27,359
Likes
69,758
krogerfoot krogerfoot
This is probably only understandable to North Americans of a certain CRS-susceptible age, but: "Hey, you got your attribution of intrinsic beauty in my enduring appreciation of a master painter!" "No, YOU got YOUR enduring appreciation of a master painter in MY attribution of intrinsic beauty!"


Who walks down the street eating a bucket of peanut butter? Who is the creepy dude invading the personal space of these two youngsters? Can art be objectively good? These questions will likely never be answered...
 
bubu16
Posts
317
Likes
249
This is like discussing religion/politics -IMO. It won't end in a good way most often than not. Let us just open our eyes and minds and try to understand each one's point and opinion. Everyone makes sense and one isn't better than the other.
 
Tony C.
Posts
7,643
Likes
26,498
And to underscore that Al and I aren't far apart on certain aspects of the discussion...

infus2.jpg
 
krogerfoot
Posts
1,068
Likes
3,703
I have noted before that black truffles are a flavorless, odorless substance that can be added to most dishes to make them cost twice as much.
 
Tony C.
Posts
7,643
Likes
26,498
Archer Archer
I did like them as a kid, but find them very sweet these days...not sure if they were always so sweet, or if this is just my tastes changing...

Probably the latter, and I react the same way. As a mature (pronounced in the upper-class British way – mah-toor) eater, I much prefer chocolate made from Sao Tome beans (75%), in combination with Pic's peanut butter (from NZ). 😁
 
Peemacgee
Posts
5,460
Likes
8,495
bubu16 bubu16
This is like discussing religion/politics -IMO. It won't end in a good way most often than not. Let us just open our eyes and minds and try to understand each one's point and opinion. Everyone makes sense and one isn't better than the other.

don’t you come in here, at the end of an argument, and try to talk sense....
 
krogerfoot
Posts
1,068
Likes
3,703
Tony C. Tony C.
Probably the latter, and I react the same way. As a mature (pronounced in the upper-class British way – mah-toor) eater, I much prefer chocolate made from Sao Tome beans (75%), in combination with Pic's peanut butter (from NZ). 😁
“But it was alright, everything was alright, the struggle was finished. He had won the victory over himself. He loved Reese's Peanut Butter Cups.”
Edited:
 
Archer
Posts
27,359
Likes
69,758
Tony C. Tony C.
And to underscore that Al and I aren't far apart on certain aspects of the discussion...

infus2.jpg

I'm an olive oil purist, so I don't want anything "infused" in my oils. I do literally drink it (doctors orders), and I prefer Spanish oils from made from Arberquina olives. It produces a very green, sharp oil that I find quite good to take on it's own, and it also goes well in many recipes.

Now olives for eating, my favourites are either Lucques or Verdale...

😀
 
Tony C.
Posts
7,643
Likes
26,498
Peemacgee Peemacgee
don’t you come in here, at the end of an argument, and try to talk sense....

It's worse than that. He apparently failed to see the intrinsic beauty of my arguments. Or did he see it, and choose to ignore it? 🙄
 
Archer
Posts
27,359
Likes
69,758
Peemacgee Peemacgee
don’t you come in here, at the end of an argument, and try to talk sense....

Is that what that was?
 
77 More Posts...
Sign up or log in to reply...

Similar threads

tyrantlizardrex

Affordable Space Art - A Couple of Acquisitions

tyrantlizardrex Open Discussion
SpeedyPhill
SpeedyPhill
Posts
50
Views
5K