Die hard vintage only buyers are going to be against it, and as a vintage guy myself, I understand their point. That said, when its done well (and it appears these new LE models are spot on) without being phony looking, I think its great. As another member mentioned, new lume will never patina no matter how old they become and part of what makes the true vintage examples so appealing is the aged patina. It gives such a nice warmth to the overall look of the watch. If Omega would have released these without aged lume, my guess is there would be more criticism of not having it vs. having it.