Advice on first purchase: Seamaster 1956 or ref.2639-12 1952

Woowon · Jan 26, 2020

Hi all! Like many others, I need some advice as I’m looking to not only purchase my first Omega, but my first watch ever. I’ve tried to do as much research as possible and read around this forum.

I’ve found two different watches that I’m interested in. I’d love to get a second opinion on the condition and price of each watch.

Omega Seamaster Automatic – 1956 – 35 mm – $516
My own thoughts: I think the watch is beautiful and the patina is very nice. The case has a decent amount of wear and tear. The crown should be original, but the bracelet has been changed. The back of the watch is engraved – which I don’t mind at all – but is it something I can use to negotiate the price?

Omega 2639-12 – 1952 – 36 mm – $610
My own thoughts: Also a beautiful watch. I’m really drawn by the sub-dial. Omega crown but the bracelet has been changed. The seller said the dial has been renovated, and I guess this is a big no no?

pablosimon2000 · Jan 26, 2020

I would not buy the second one. Dial is renewed. Nice, but redone! About the first one, without being an expert, it looks like an honest piece. No idea about price!! Good luck with the hunt.

Peter_from_NL · Jan 26, 2020

Number two is not original. I personally love inscriptions. Given it a unique feeling and some historic value. Others however, think it lowers the value. I would be in the market for number one. Also because at this side of the globe (the Netherlands) I don’t see that price.... ;(

speedb · Jan 26, 2020

I don't like the Seamaster font on the first watch, the 'coathanger' shaped S was much more common in the 1950s. I tend to see the more rounded S design appear on later rotary automatic pieces. The font also seems a bit too bold, compared to font on the rest of the watch, suggesting a redial.
If I'm not making much sense, this thread might help: https://omegaforums.net/threads/question-re-seamaster-font.68732/
Additionally, the number six numeral looks like it's been poorly reattached to the dial, and the top of the number 3 numeral looks broken.

thelinendial · Jan 26, 2020

Agree with speedb comments about the first one...

But if you wanted to choose btw the two I'd vote for the first one.

seekingseaquest · Jan 26, 2020

The dial on the first one is okay, but it has been cleaned and I wouldn’t be surprised if that leftover patina isn’t all that even/attractive in better lighting. That paired with the inscription on the case back is a pass for me.

Agreed with previous comments on the second.

I recommend being patient and looking for better examples.

Woowon · Jan 27, 2020

Thanks for all the replies - much appreciated!

speedb
I don't like the Seamaster font on the first watch, the 'coathanger' shaped S was much more common in the 1950s. I tend to see the more rounded S design appear on later rotary automatic pieces. The font also seems a bit too bold, compared to font on the rest of the watch, suggesting a redial.
If I'm not making much sense, this thread might help: https://omegaforums.net/threads/question-re-seamaster-font.68732/
Additionally, the number six numeral looks like it's been poorly reattached to the dial, and the top of the number 3 numeral looks broken.

Ah very interesting about the Seamaster font! And I notice the numerals now when you pointed it out. Thank you!

seekingseaquest
The dial on the first one is okay, but it has been cleaned and I wouldn’t be surprised if that leftover patina isn’t all that even/attractive in better lighting. That paired with the inscription on the case back is a pass for me.

Agreed with previous comments on the second.

I recommend being patient and looking for better examples.

I'll probably end up with your recommendation and hold off until I find something better.

Dr.K · Jan 27, 2020

1st one is a good one. I’d buy it but already own a 58. 😀

avoid the 2nd. Just feels off.

Advice on first purchase: Seamaster 1956 or ref.2639-12 1952

Woowon

pablosimon2000

Peter_from_NL

speedb

thelinendial

seekingseaquest

Woowon

Dr.K

Similar threads

Advice on Buying My First Vintage Seamaster (166.010 or 168.022)

Newbie Seeks Opinion on First Purchase: Longines Anniversary

Opinion sought on first purchase (Omega this time): Black Seamaster

Help on first purchase

New To Forum. Questions On First Purchase Seamaster