A question about service of a Cal 561

Posts
1,867
Likes
2,274
I admit I did not think of the crystal ring. Thanks Al.
 
Posts
163
Likes
211
I admit I did not think of the crystal ring. Thanks Al.
The problem turned out to be the rotor. The watchmaker replaced it and now all is well. Thanks to all who provided advice, especially Al who laid out all the alternatives.
Edited:
 
Posts
4,402
Likes
5,797
Thnx for sharing @dstern as we’ve seen many comments on here with this issue, and first I can recall where’s it’s actually repaired real time as the discussion. A good real-time example!
 
Posts
346
Likes
286
Rotor trouble seems to be a common issue with this movement. My Connie 168.005 had a loose rotor too, the rotor had lots of lateral play and it is my understanding that a worn bushing was the issue. My watchmaker replaced it and there's no lateral play in the rotor anymore however I do occasionally hear it make a clicking noise, as if it's now hitting one of the plates in the movement. It's only occasionally that I hear it so I'm not sure if it's just a quirk or if it needs investigation.
 
Posts
163
Likes
211
Thnx for sharing @dstern as we’ve seen many comments on here with this issue, and first I can recall where’s it’s actually repaired real time as the discussion. A good real-time example!
I'm happy to contribute, and of course delighted that the real time advice made a real difference.
 
Posts
28,067
Likes
71,665
Rotor trouble seems to be a common issue with this movement. My Connie 168.005 had a loose rotor too, the rotor had lots of lateral play and it is my understanding that a worn bushing was the issue. My watchmaker replaced it and there's no lateral play in the rotor anymore however I do occasionally hear it make a clicking noise, as if it's now hitting one of the plates in the movement. It's only occasionally that I hear it so I'm not sure if it's just a quirk or if it needs investigation.

Keep in mind that rotors by nature typically have a very thin cross section from the area near the axle (or bearing) leading out to the edge where the weight is. The thin plate can be subject to deflection, so if the watch receives a shock it's not impossible for that to bend enough to have momentary contact with the edges of a bridge on the movement, causing that clicking sound.

The flexing can even crack this area of the rotor over time if the design is weak, like so:



Now as I mentioned previously in this thread, I've seen rotors bent to try to provide clearance instead of fixing the bushing, so it's possible that if there is a bend or twist in the rotor it may be closer to the bridges than it should be, and even a small external force causes it to hit the bridge. The only way to know it to open the watch and inspect the gap as you turn the rotor to see how close it is - I often see them with a slight twist that I correct using #8 tweezers...

Cheers, Al
 
Posts
163
Likes
211
I just realized that I never posted pictures of the Connie after it was repaired. I'll start with a before picture.
 
Posts
163
Likes
211
And here are some photos of the watch after it was repaired.
 
Posts
163
Likes
211
This was my first Connie, so long as i exclude the one that UPS lost, and I'm grateful for all I've learned from the OF members.
Edited: