A new brown dial Speedmaster

Posts
108
Likes
88
I don't know why this kind of dial is so highly valued.
In a world of uniformity and mass production, some people want to step out of the line and value uniqueness. When most Speedmasters have a black dial, any outlier becomes attractive (to them). Some people value the damaged/patinated dials, while others want a factory-new, perfect condition. The free market can please everyone and decide the price.
 
Posts
20,238
Likes
46,930
I don't know why this kind of dial is so highly valued.
They are different and some people (including me) find them appealing, but TBH the added value is generally fairly modest. The speedmaster101 articles suggests a 4x-5x multiple, and maybe that was true at one time, but I don't think that's common. These days, I would be surprised to see more than a 50% premium, and generally less.
 
Posts
9,540
Likes
15,043
Patrizzi style.
Don't bore us with Rolex nonsense.
In a world of uniformity and mass production, some people want to step out of the line and value uniqueness. When most Speedmasters have a black dial, any outlier becomes attractive (to them). Some people value the damaged/patinated dials, while others want a factory-new, perfect condition. The free market can please everyone and decide the price.
You are AI and I claim my £5
 
Posts
9,540
Likes
15,043
Sorry, I don't get it. Could you please explain?
I didn't mean it too seriously but your earlier post showed some of the hallmarks of AI. We have had some AI posts here of late. The fact you are replying suggests that it likely isnt the case, generally AI doesn't engage in chatting, despite the name!
 
Posts
108
Likes
88
Oh, I see, no, I am a bag of meat and bones 😀 I guess I went a bit philosophical there...
 
Posts
172
Likes
297
I personally love the warmth of the dial. Especially when set against a the bezel fading towards blue.
 
Posts
172
Likes
297
Slightly off topic here but I was just thinking this the other day…

Omega made a modern brown dial a decade ago, and they were not LEs but at the same time they were never big sellers. Since then those Ref 311.30.42.30.13.001 sapphire sandwich models, which were made as a tribute to the watches posted above have almost fallen off the map entirely. I haven’t seen one on eBay in auction form, or here, or even in the WRUW thread in ages, which makes me wonder if they might be one of the least common modern Moonwatch models to have not really gone up in price and demand.
https://www.ebay.de/itm/39552628608...5338588705&toolid=20006&customid=EB263048919&

Is this an example?
 
This website may earn commission from Ebay sales.
Posts
118
Likes
213
Yeah, there's something different about a vintage speedie. There's a warmth and personality each one contrasted against the sterile precision of the current edition. Is the new 3861 superior in technology, yes, but in 50 years it will still look brand new. It won't have the character of a bygone era when the space race was in full swing.

 
Posts
27,359
Likes
69,760
They are different and some people (including me) find them appealing, but TBH the added value is generally fairly modest. The speedmaster101 articles suggests a 4x-5x multiple, and maybe that was true at one time, but I don't think that's common. These days, I would be surprised to see more than a 50% premium, and generally less.
They seemed to be more of a thing a few years ago. I've seen plenty up close during servicing, and generally if the colour isn't even, I'm not personally a fan. The few that I have seen that were very even, made me question if they were artificially aged. So overall it's just not my thing, but still I understand why people like them.

This one was bought by a customer of mine from a large well known dealer. The movement had many issues, but the dial was very even...maybe too even...



The minute wheel post had worn, and the previous watch hack had replaced it - just a tiny bit of play there, eh?



He had ground down a winding stem, and jammed it in a hole:



It was properly repaired before it went back:

 
Posts
20,238
Likes
46,930
They seemed to be more of a thing a few years ago. I've seen plenty up close during servicing, and generally if the colour isn't even, I'm not personally a fan. The few that I have seen that were very even, made me question if they were artificially aged. So overall it's just not my thing, but still I understand why people like them.

This one was bought by a customer of mine from a large well known dealer. The movement had many issues, but the dial was very even...maybe too even...



The minute wheel post had worn, and the previous watch hack had replaced it - just a tiny bit of play there, eh?



He had ground down a winding stem, and jammed it in a hole:



It was properly repaired before it went back:

I like them too, TBH, but not at a 4x-5x premium. Mine has gradations of brown across the dial. I paid a little extra for it, but that was partly because the overall condition was excellent. If it had cost me even 2x the price for an equivalent example with a black dial, I would have passed.

At one time, I had another brown dial 145.022-69 in one of the correct serial ranges, but the dial wasn't as appealing and the overall condition wasn't as good. I don't think I got a premium for it at all when I sold it.
 
Posts
172
Likes
297


Was it common for the tropic dials to also have the blue dials? I think the blue and brown really complimented each other in the most unpredicted beautiful way.
 
Posts
20,238
Likes
46,930


Was it common for the tropic dials to also have the blue dials? I think the blue and brown really complimented each other in the most unpredicted beautiful way.
I honestly can't see much brown in that dial at all, and I would be cautious in my expectations about the blue bezel. Those photos are often manipulated.
 
Posts
87
Likes
86
@Archer - were the brown dials you questioned within or outside of the know serial range for browns?

I find the experience of looking at an inky black dial Speedmaster equally satisfying to looking at a nice rich even brown dial. For me, both are worth owning in a collection, and because the market places a premium to own a brown, than I pay to play.
 
Posts
2,124
Likes
6,537
I love brown dials as well, and the one from OP is quite appealing. They’re mesmerizing in sunlight.

Here is mine next to a ‘71.

 
Posts
27,359
Likes
69,760
@Archer - were the brown dials you questioned within or outside of the know serial range for browns?

I find the experience of looking at an inky black dial Speedmaster equally satisfying to looking at a nice rich even brown dial. For me, both are worth owning in a collection, and because the market places a premium to own a brown, than I pay to play.
Sorry - no idea. In practical terms that is a "collector thing" not really a "watchmaker thing"...I'm just servicing the watch for someone. I do hope they did their research so they didn't get ripped off, but for me looking at serial number ranges to determine if it falls within the range from brown dials - that's pretty low on my priority list when I'm slammed with work.