145.022-68 Transitional Speedmaster, polished or not?

Posts
303
Likes
308
Here for example.
I had the opportunity to observe this live at the speedy tuesday event, and I can assure that the sound one has the lines.
At the same event I had a talk with an omega engineer which assured that the lines are due to the manufacturing.

Of course the line is there, but what the above picture shows is the dark line between brushed and shiny (don't want to use the term polished).
What happens, over time that corner wears down and therefore roundens off.
When they come in later to redo the brushed finish, depending on how bad the corner has worn, it will not clean up and still leave that little area shown above that reflects light differently and therefore appears dark.

The picture you provided of the moonshine gold model doesn't show that condition.

To answer the OPs question: in my opinion the watch case has been refinished. Again I don't want to use the term polished, because refinishing a case doesn't necessarily mean polishing it.
 
Posts
1,100
Likes
1,701
Of course the line is there, but what the above picture shows is the dark line between brushed and shiny (don't want to use the term polished).
What happens, over time that corner wears down and therefore roundens off.
When they come in later to redo the brushed finish, depending on how bad the corner has worn, it will not clean up and still leave that little area shown above that reflects light differently and therefore appears dark.

The picture you provided of the moonshine gold model doesn't show that condition.

To answer the OPs question: in my opinion the watch case has been refinished. Again I don't want to use the term polished, because refinishing a case doesn't necessarily mean polishing it.

We were talking about different lines!
 
Posts
2,315
Likes
5,697
In no way would I pay a premium for any watch that was described this way, and in general I avoid sales that make these claims.
So easy to tell an unpolished Speedmaster from a polished one...
I would say that this OP example has been polished based on these pictures.
One of the more decent/professional jobs that you could find. Looks like it was most likely done by Omega service center or a very skilled refinisher. Definitely not one of your "Jeweler's Special" hack polishing jobs which completely destroy the lines of the case.
 
Posts
29,671
Likes
76,828
So easy to tell an unpolished Speedmaster from a polished one...

It’s typically the guys who own or sell these “unpolished” watches that are so adamant about it. If you feel you can tell the difference, that’s up to you. I will continue to view these claims with a healthy dose of skepticism.
 
Posts
2,315
Likes
5,697
It’s typically the guys who own or sell these “unpolished” watches that are so adamant about it. If you feel you can tell the difference, that’s up to you. I will continue to view these claims with a healthy dose of skepticism.
I guess it all comes down to experience...
 
Posts
29,671
Likes
76,828
I guess it all comes down to experience...

Indeed it does...