Where would you trust to buy a 2531.80 - Brosnan Seamaster

Posts
318
Likes
1,963
Hi Everyone,

Despite being a decades long Omega fan and having a few - I've never bought pre-owned. I love my 300Ms - and my white one is frequent daily driver. Lately, however, I've been thinking how fun it would be to 2531.80 - box and papers.

Yet - it is a watch of increasing popularity and ( as ever ) I'm concerned about fakes. Assuming I have a bias for professional dealers - where would you go? Where would you look? How would you know you've got "a good one"? Do you think it is safe on eBay?
 
Posts
480
Likes
637
Hi Everyone,

Despite being a decades long Omega fan and having a few - I've never bought pre-owned. I love my 300Ms - and my white one is frequent daily driver. Lately, however, I've been thinking how fun it would be to 2531.80 - box and papers.

Yet - it is a watch of increasing popularity and ( as ever ) I'm concerned about fakes. Assuming I have a bias for professional dealers - where would you go? Where would you look? How would you know you've got "a good one"? Do you think it is safe on eBay?
There are many of these on c24 and eBay, which are both generally safe. You could start there to get a sense of pricing/condition (assuming there are none here FS; I haven't checked), and then look for the dealers' names and try to find their own websites. Often their prices are lower there due to no c24/ebay fees, and they often discount further eg if you pay by wire. I don't think there are many fakes of these. And I would think "a good one" pretty much just depends on condition since you're saying you're looking for a full set. I would also look for a tritium example (pre-~'98), since patina'd lume is much more pleasing IMO. They would also be less likely to be faked I think. So "good condition" would be a clean dial, in-tact lume of a pleasing color, all original parts (typically the bezel and hands in this case), a minimally polished case, a not-too-scratched bezel, etc. Good luck!
 
Posts
265
Likes
636
There is a seller on WatchUSeek named Exelonman (David Evans.) He specializes in Seamasters of that vintage, the next generation, Peter Blakes, and some newer ones sometimes. I've purchased a number of watches from him and he has many, many good reviews. He is very trustworthy. I highly recommend him.
 
Posts
439
Likes
1,009
There are many of these on c24 and eBay, which are both generally safe. You could start there to get a sense of pricing/condition (assuming there are none here FS; I haven't checked), and then look for the dealers' names and try to find their own websites. Often their prices are lower there due to no c24/ebay fees, and they often discount further eg if you pay by wire. I don't think there are many fakes of these. And I would think "a good one" pretty much just depends on condition since you're saying you're looking for a full set. I would also look for a tritium example (pre-~'98), since patina'd lume is much more pleasing IMO. They would also be less likely to be faked I think. So "good condition" would be a clean dial, in-tact lume of a pleasing color, all original parts (typically the bezel and hands in this case), a minimally polished case, a not-too-scratched bezel, etc. Good luck!

Yep in addition to the notes above, also make sure the serial number hasn't been polished off the rear of the lug. That used to happen to some grey market watches back then, apparently. Have seen that catch some people out on here. And broadly, stick with sellers with lots of sales and positive feedback.

Also, subjectively, I don't love the tritium dialed Bonds. I feel like the egg yellow lume clashes with the blue, and tritium models seem more likely to have faded bezels and red seconds turned white as well. Personally, I'd aim for a 1998+ Super LumiNova model with the original minty white lume. But that's just me.
 
Posts
318
Likes
1,963
Yep in addition to the notes above, also make sure the serial number hasn't been polished off the rear of the lug. That used to happen to some grey market watches back then, apparently. Have seen that catch some people out on here. And broadly, stick with sellers with lots of sales and positive feedback.

Also, subjectively, I don't love the tritium dialed Bonds. I feel like the egg yellow lume clashes with the blue, and tritium models seem more likely to have faded bezels and red seconds turned white as well. Personally, I'd aim for a 1998+ Super LumiNova model with the original minty white lume. But that's just me.

I can't disagree - Some of the models immediately following are also great.
 
Posts
439
Likes
1,009
I can't disagree - Some of the models immediately following are also great.

Yep the dial on the model after the Brosnan automatic is for sure a bit more premium, the applied indices and red lettering are quite nice, plus you get the co-axial movement. Then you get into the ceramic models. Still, I prefer the Brosnan era watch. It has the sleekest case and simplest dial, plus I like the more retro style caseback with the wave print and Seamaster medallion.
 
Posts
1,336
Likes
17,016
You can't go wrong with the 2531.80! I second the recommendation for Exelonman – I've purchased from him in the past without any issues. If you can find a well-cared for example with a Super-LumiNova dial, it's really easy to freshen up its appearance with a blue NATO strap or a mesh bracelet.

 
Posts
439
Likes
1,009
You can't go wrong with the 2531.80! I second the recommendation for Exelonman – I've purchased from him in the past without any issues. If you can find a well-cared for example with a Super-LumiNova dial, it's really easy to freshen up its appearance with a blue NATO strap or a mesh bracelet.


Nice, is that a blue Omega polyester? I didn't know they did those! I have a blue polyamide for my 2541.80, though these days I'm running it on the current gen rubber, which is my favourite combo other than the stock bracelet.

 
Posts
1,336
Likes
17,016
Nice, is that a blue Omega polyester?
Yep - but I do not recommend. The fabric quickly shows signs of wear and feels cheap. The polyamide straps are much better.
 
Posts
207
Likes
167
You can't go wrong with the 2531.80! I second the recommendation for Exelonman – I've purchased from him in the past without any issues. If you can find a well-cared for example with a Super-LumiNova dial, it's really easy to freshen up its appearance with a blue NATO strap or a mesh bracelet.

Man, that blue Nato does the trick.
 
Posts
3,544
Likes
36,985
Such a classic watch, I got a small wrist so I have the medium size one, can't remember the reference number... Aside from its bracelet, I've worn it with a green straps, a mesh bracelet, even on a white rubber.

Very versatile

 
Posts
439
Likes
1,009
Got inspired here. Thought the grey strap worked well with the faded bezel.

Very cool combo, nicely done. Out of interest, is the seconds hand a service replacement? Often when I see these ghost bezels, the red on the seconds hand has faded white as well. They also usually seem to be tritium models for some reason.
 
Posts
1,512
Likes
2,900
Such a classic watch, I got a small wrist so I have the medium size one, can't remember the reference number... Aside from its bracelet, I've worn it with a green straps, a mesh bracelet, even on a white rubber.

Very versatile

It's a 2551.80
I have one too. Your post has given me a bit of inspiration as I'm starting to find the styling of the original bracelet a bit dated. Mesh really does freshen it up, as does a NATO.
 
Posts
207
Likes
167
Very cool combo, nicely done. Out of interest, is the seconds hand a service replacement? Often when I see these ghost bezels, the red on the seconds hand has faded white as well. They also usually seem to be tritium models for some reason.
Not that I'm aware of. This one still has the original factory wax on caseback deeming it never opened.
 
Posts
2
Likes
3
Hi Everyone,

Despite being a decades long Omega fan and having a few - I've never bought pre-owned. I love my 300Ms - and my white one is frequent daily driver. Lately, however, I've been thinking how fun it would be to 2531.80 - box and papers.

Yet - it is a watch of increasing popularity and ( as ever ) I'm concerned about fakes. Assuming I have a bias for professional dealers - where would you go? Where would you look? How would you know you've got "a good one"? Do you think it is safe on eBay?
Curious if you ever found one and, if so, where? I am looking for the right one now and would love to hear how things went for you.

I’ve been looking at watchyouseek this week and saw some great examples recently sold that I really wish were still available. This will be my first luxury watch and after obsessively looking at watches in person and online for about 6 months, I really feel drawn to this specific reference and am certain it’s the one I want. I want one on really good shape to be a daily wearer that will age with me!