- Posts
- 391
- Likes
- 336
1st speedy
·... Or a vintage watch that's been fully overhauled? I prefer a watch that's as original as possible.... And running.
What's more valuable to you? Untouched vintage or...
- Posts
- 5,636
- Likes
- 5,811
SkunkPrince
·After I buy a vintage watch, it gets fully overhauled. I wear mine, not gaze lovingly at them.
- Posts
- 3,255
- Likes
- 14,142
Vitezi
·I wear mine and gaze lovingly at them 😀
- Posts
- 5,082
- Likes
- 15,701
DaveK
·... Or a vintage watch that's been fully overhauled? I prefer a watch that's as original as possible.... And running.
- Posts
- 6,684
- Likes
- 52,560
noelekal
··Home For Wayward WatchesI love vintage cars, but I want new fuel in the tank, fresh oil in the crank case,.and fresh wiper blades.
- Posts
- 371
- Likes
- 260
- Posts
- 1,071
- Likes
- 2,167
jsducote
·"A weapon unused is a useless weapon." - General Sline
- Posts
- 538
- Likes
- 2,523
- Posts
- 1,430
- Likes
- 2,957
Marsimaxam
·My question to you is...Define overhaul?
Definitely prefer my watches all original, but not unserviced. Now, if by overhaul, you mean what Omega service will do to your vintage watch... change crown, dial, pushers and hands... NO. But a watch is essentially a machine and it needs to be maintained or it will not function properly and eventually breakdown. I just bought a mint almost NOS watch, and, although it was keeping perfect time as tested by the watchmaker, there was no service mark inside the case back and the gasket was completely deteriorated... not taking a chance... the watch is now being serviced, but, it will be returned to me with most of the original parts... obviously the gasket will no longer be original to the watch.
Definitely prefer my watches all original, but not unserviced. Now, if by overhaul, you mean what Omega service will do to your vintage watch... change crown, dial, pushers and hands... NO. But a watch is essentially a machine and it needs to be maintained or it will not function properly and eventually breakdown. I just bought a mint almost NOS watch, and, although it was keeping perfect time as tested by the watchmaker, there was no service mark inside the case back and the gasket was completely deteriorated... not taking a chance... the watch is now being serviced, but, it will be returned to me with most of the original parts... obviously the gasket will no longer be original to the watch.
- Posts
- 391
- Likes
- 336
1st speedy
·I love vintage cars, but I want new fuel in the tank, fresh oil in the crank case,.and fresh wiper blades.
Remember, this is for collection.
- Posts
- 1,523
- Likes
- 1,678
nanjingcigaretes
·Yes, If two watch are in the same condition, I would go with serviced one. My choice.
- Posts
- 101
- Likes
- 241
Romega
·If the watch is for use - serviced
If the watch is for collection - untouched (you can always have it serviced later)
If the watch is for collection - untouched (you can always have it serviced later)
- Posts
- 1,488
- Likes
- 2,376
asrnj77
·Of course if it was only a movement service everybody would take a serviced watch. The reason this is even a debate is because “fully overhauled” insinuates replacement crowns, bezel inserts, relumed hands, etc. The barn/sock drawer finds always get more money because the buyer feels more confident that the watch is unmolested and they can have their own service performed. For what it’s worth, I prefer the original watch and I’ll pay to have the movement serviced on my own
- Posts
- 5,074
- Likes
- 15,651
eugeneandresson
·fully overhauled
That depends on exactly what you mean by this...however, I prefer untouched vintage whose movement I can get fully overhauled by someone I trust.
- Posts
- 4,643
- Likes
- 9,349
Bill Sohne
··Bill @ ΩFHi everyone
This is a topic that never goes away..... I always prefer " as found in the wild" not " as found from a dealer" . If a dealer finds a watch they sometime calls me and ask if I have interest.. First thing I tell them " dont do anything to it until i see it" and then I would make a call one way or the other.
movement serviced , gaskets changed ( if available ) is a good thing.
But first rule is " always buy what you like " ...... sometimes the watch has been "serviced" cleaned , polished etc...
Good Hunting
Bill Sohne
This is a topic that never goes away..... I always prefer " as found in the wild" not " as found from a dealer" . If a dealer finds a watch they sometime calls me and ask if I have interest.. First thing I tell them " dont do anything to it until i see it" and then I would make a call one way or the other.
movement serviced , gaskets changed ( if available ) is a good thing.
But first rule is " always buy what you like " ...... sometimes the watch has been "serviced" cleaned , polished etc...
Good Hunting
Bill Sohne
- Posts
- 13,714
- Likes
- 53,536
Larry S
··Color Commentator for the Hyperbole.So if you had a choice between an all original ac cobra with original tires, battery and even wiper blades and an ac cobra mostly original, you'd pick the "mostly original"?
Remember, this is for collection.
- Posts
- 3,742
- Likes
- 6,360
- Posts
- 6,684
- Likes
- 52,560
noelekal
··Home For Wayward WatchesSo if you had a choice between an all original ac cobra with original tires, battery and even wiper blades and an ac cobra mostly original, you'd pick the "mostly original"?
Remember, this is for collection.
You gonna fire up that that AC Cobra's engine on a 55-57 year old battery, depend on 55-57 year old oil for lubrication, drive it at speed on 55-57 year old rubber? For the purposes of discussion we'll assume that you won't take the car out on a rainy day so won't need the 55-57 year old wiper blades.
How far are we going to take this originality with this hypothetical AC Cobra? I mean ... we wouldn't want to disturb the original configuration of the factory's original application of original wheel bearing grease by rolling the car up and down the ramps of its transport trailer.
Remember you said: " ... and running."
... Or a vintage watch that's been fully overhauled? I prefer a watch that's as original as possible.... And running.
What if you have 200 vintage cars?
Only one opinion on this topic, but if I am to buy an all original AC Cobra then I am going to possess it and experience it and not just as an ornament for my garage. I might save all those original maintenance items for display, but the car would be put in running order so that I might drive it.
If a person gets their kicks out of playing museum curator, conserving a pristine example of an object they possess, then great! I'm grateful that there are those kinds of collectors in the world. I'm not that person. I'm a member of the hoi polloi, a consumer, a collector (accumulator?) who wants an experience with the collected object beyond being its museum curator so it would be best to keep my mitts off the rare stuff for I'll use it every time.
Edited:
- Posts
- 4,593
- Likes
- 10,810
janice&fred
·I prefer the original watch and I’ll pay to have the movement serviced on my own
Yep. If I have a choice I prefer my own tech handling the innards of my watches.
- Posts
- 4,643
- Likes
- 9,349
Bill Sohne
··Bill @ ΩFWhat if you have 200 vintage cars?
200 vintage cars sounds like a high class problem.
Good Hunting
Bill
Similar threads
- Posts
- 13
- Views
- 1K
- Posts
- 4
- Views
- 582
- Posts
- 0
- Views
- 257
- Posts
- 14
- Views
- 6K
- Posts
- 2
- Views
- 2K