What would you do with these hands?

M'Bob · Oct 12, 2022

Originally, I was going to stabilize the cracking luminous with binder. Then, I noticed upon careful inspection that there are rust spots and paint loss to the chrono hand, and paint flaking on the minute hand, and quite a bit at the base of both the minute and hour hand, if you expand the photo. So would you:

1) Leave it as is, and just stabilize the lume

2) Scrape the rust off and re-paint the paint loss areas

3) Get the hands and luminous completely restored

4) Replace with a set of better hands

Larry S · Oct 12, 2022

I like honesty in a vintage watch so I vote leave as is and stabilize.

bananapeanut · Oct 12, 2022

I vote for option 1 as well. It doesn't look that bad.

gbesq · Oct 12, 2022

3. Reluming the hands won’t devalue the watch significantly and rust spreads. Fix it before it gets worse.

fiberguy · Oct 12, 2022

Rust never sleeps ... quite literally.

Slevin kelevra · Oct 12, 2022

Better set of hands. They would lift the watch a lot.

watch_my_six · Oct 12, 2022

I would do whatever is needed to prevent further degradation, i.e. if there is risk of the rust spreading, then stop the rust (and if that entails repainting the hands, then so be it), and stabilize the lume (but stop short of re-luming, since the lume itself still appears mostly fine, and not unpleasant, just aged, and mostly consistent with the dial).

M'Bob · Oct 12, 2022

The rust issue is indeed the biggest problem. It’s hard to see from the picture, but the tail end of the chrono hand has rust beginning to bubble up under it. I’m torn as to whether it’s a Pandora’s box to try and remedy it.

dsio · Oct 12, 2022

I’d be going #3 but that’s a very sharp watch overall, I don’t think I could leave them as is when they’re the only thing going against a very nice Speedy.

Darlinboy · Oct 12, 2022

I'd look for a set of vintage correct hands.

M'Bob · Nov 3, 2022

Darlinboy
I'd look for a set of vintage correct hands.

Couldn’t deal with the likely on-going chipping and flaking into the movement. Here with its new hands:

Darlinboy · Nov 3, 2022

M'Bob
Couldn’t deal with the likely on-going chipping and flaking into the movement. Here with its new hands:

well done then. 👍

noelekal · Nov 3, 2022

Very pretty!

M'Bob · Nov 3, 2022

Darlinboy
well done then. 👍

noelekal
Very pretty!

I never appreciated the visual dynamic until the hands were replaced, but it occurs to me that the incongruence of the chip draws your eye right to it, and thus you tend to immediately ignore, and less appreciate, other aspects of the watch.

watch_my_six · Nov 3, 2022

Looks like you replaced the small chrono hands too? And what kind of replacement hands are all of them?

M'Bob · Nov 4, 2022

jspdl
Looks like you replaced the small chrono hands too? And what kind of replacement hands are all of them?

They are are restored set I bought years ago. Can’t remember from who, or for how much. But they are Tritium.

morethan1 · Nov 4, 2022

Looks better and you can sleep at night knowing the rust won’t spread.

Pvt-Public · Nov 5, 2022

morethan1
Looks better and you can sleep at night knowing the rust won’t spread.

Ah, but the rust will continue, just not while they are in the watch😉.

What would you do with these hands?

M'Bob

Larry S

bananapeanut

gbesq

fiberguy

Slevin kelevra

watch_my_six

M'Bob

dsio

Darlinboy

M'Bob

Darlinboy

noelekal

M'Bob

watch_my_six

M'Bob

morethan1

Pvt-Public

Similar threads

What would you do?

Any familiar with what lume is on these hands?

What do you do with straps/bracelets from used watches

Omega Geneve f300 - what would you do?

Speedmaster—What would you do advice?

Originality vs. sympathetic restoration: What would you do?