I have a friend who is an audio engineer (designs and builds amps & preamps). For fun we put a Dynaco ST70 (bargain kit tube amp back the day) that he had completely rebuilt and redesigned, on a scope to check its performance. Sine waves were decent to a point but the square waves were horrible as soon as it hit 12khz- just started rounding off (which was common in those amps regardless of how well overhauled).
I asked him what it meant and he said that in theory it means the amp should have horrible transient response, rolled off high end and be distorted at the top. But when lisenting it was superb, extended, shimmering on the top end.
He said he had tested amps that scoped perfectly but would sound lifeless and sterile- almost put you to sleep.
I know whatches and audio are apples and oranges, but sometimes just because it doesn’t test well doesn’t mean it won’t keep “decent” time and it isn’t enjoyable.
Click to expand...