Dial damage is very much a personal choice, and also related to price/value. Overall spotting can sometimes be appealing, but I find my eye is drawn to big spots or scratches, and I would really try to avoid those. There is some lume loss in the minute hand in the first, and the lume is completely gone in the hands of the second one. This can be restored obviously.
Overall, I would expect both of these to have relatively low prices, otherwise I wouldn't consider them. Keep in mind, that they may need a full service, either now or in the near future, so you may be forced to invest yet another $200 or more into which ever one you buy.
Click to expand...