What are correct hands for a Tri-Compax Moonphase (cal 287) 1940's

Posts
344
Likes
434
I commonly see either the thin, sword style (usually gold) or the fat, plongeur style. Which would be correct?

Presumably, for the 1940s, these would be pre-tritium lume? Perhaps radium?

(images: Google)

 
Posts
24,256
Likes
54,009
I imagine it depends on the dial, since some have lume and some don't. There might even be more styles.
 
Posts
1,644
Likes
8,283
We can wait on some of those more in the know, but I think that Dan is correct-dials with lume seemed to generally have hands with lume and a dial with no lume should generally have hands with no lume. Here are a couple examples of the latter.

 
Posts
344
Likes
434
I imagine it depends on the dial, since some have lume and some don't. There might even be more styles.
Curiously, I have not come across dials with lume pips. Perhaps I need to look longer, and perhaps they’ve just fallen off and been removed.

Also dials don’t seem to show radium burn, which makes me wonder what the lume material is on these plongeur hands.
 
Posts
344
Likes
434
My ex watch with ex hands like OP pic one

Oh now this ones interesting. That green looks like radium. Did you ever take a giger counter to this? After ~80(?) years of radiation exposure, wouldn’t the dial be more toasty looking?
 
Posts
24,256
Likes
54,009
Curiously, I have not come across dials with lume pips. Perhaps I need to look longer, and perhaps they’ve just fallen off and been removed.

Also dials don’t seem to show radium burn, which makes me wonder what the lume material is on these plongeur hands.

The dial lume is often on the numerals. Some numerals are lumed, some are painted. You need to look closely at good photos.
 
Posts
344
Likes
434
The dial lume is often on the numerals. Some numerals are lumed, some are painted. You need to look closely at good photos.
Ah, I’m seeing what you’re talking about now. I mistook many for paint, or even refinish. But you’re right - they have that green-black moldy hue.
 
Posts
13,698
Likes
53,498
Lumed hands = Lumed dial indices... always. Sometimes the dial can be painted not lumed. Then non lumed hands are ok.
Edited:
 
Posts
3,586
Likes
8,280
There are many possible types of dial and hand combinations, it's one of the cool things about UG ! Also makes it frustrating to try and catagorize definitively.

Better to look at individual examples, rather than generalizations.

The lume for the types of examples being shared in this thread so far is radium, and yes they def register on a meter.

One thing that I find interesting is the range of possible aging on the dial lume vs hand lume often seems quite varied, and more often than not, they don't match.

That very first pic in this thread is good example, offhand that looks to be original radium on the dial and hands.
 
Posts
2,070
Likes
14,603
Oh now this ones interesting. That green looks like radium. Did you ever take a giger counter to this? After ~80(?) years of radiation exposure, wouldn’t the dial be more toasty looking?
I did - it was off the charts - I sold the watch!
 
Posts
344
Likes
434
I did - it was off the charts - I sold the watch!
I don't blame you! Some of those look absolutely deadly! In a gorgeous, sexy sorta way...
 
Posts
220
Likes
314
Don't forget the radon gas they emit when decaying. Radium watches kept in non ventilated areas is deadly. I have a radon detector and it shocked me. Was like 10x safe levels with only one watch.
 
Posts
3,586
Likes
8,280
Don't forget the radon gas they emit when decaying. Radium watches kept in non ventilated areas is deadly. I have a radon detector and it shocked me. Was like 10x safe levels with only one watch.

How would you define a non ventilated area? Is there any room in a residential house that would be considered non ventilated?
 
Posts
30
Likes
63
How would you define a non ventilated area? Is there any room in a residential house that would be considered non ventilated?

+1

Not to de-rail the thread too much, but I would also like to know. What do folks recommend for best practices in regards to safely collecting radium watches?