Watch too big?

Posts
12
Likes
35
Just looking for opinions. I think it is slightly big, but it’s just on the edge. 42mm case lug to lug just over 51mm. I’m still in the warranty period so might return it.
 
Posts
12
Likes
35
Too big.
Yeah. The lugs are quite long at 51.5mm, just checked online. Sucks because the smaller version has an integrated bracelet and would look silly on a different strap. Search continues
 
Posts
222
Likes
226
Lugs are not hanging over your wrist and on side shot, not sticking away from the curvature of your wrist. I say rock it, if it feels comfortable.
 
Posts
726
Likes
2,696
It looks fine to me. Not the perfect size for you, but I don't think that's big. If it feels right on your wrist, it's fine. I would make sure not to scratch the lower lugs with the buckle being that close to them. Can you adjust that?
 
Posts
1,032
Likes
4,333
Looks fine to me. As long as there isn't any overhang you're good. And yeah whats going on with that strap. I think you put the nato on backwards.
 
Posts
819
Likes
2,233
Looks pretty giant and bet that nato pushes it out off your wrist. I bet it will bang into everything.
 
Posts
73
Likes
222
I think the NATO strap is the problem - a leather or rubber strap might be better
 
Posts
628
Likes
719
Is the warranty period allowing to return it for this reason though?

I found out that something that bothered me on a watch rarely goes away - changing straps can help, but just a bit.

If you wear smaller watches frequently, then you might always be surprised by the size when you pick it up.

If it bothers you, then I would seek to exchange it. After all it needs to feel right to get some wrist time.
 
Posts
2,432
Likes
6,847
Nice Seiko 👍 , but yes it looks a tad big, but if you like the watch, who cares? Five years ago it would have seemed small, fashions change.

I (we?) have these taughts every 6 months or so "is it too big" then I forget about it and enjoy my watch.
 
Posts
232
Likes
946
I have 6.5" wrists yet enjoyed wearing a 42mm Speedie, daily for 15years straight - on a variety of metal, leather and NATO straps.

I now have a modest collection of perhaps 20 watches - the majority of which is in the 34-36mm range

I would estimate that my old Speedie has been on my wrist less than a dozen times in the past 5 years.

What strikes me is how much my preference has shifted over the years - who knows may shift back to the larger pieces
 
Posts
7,075
Likes
13,183
The strap is too bulky, one reason I don't like NATO style straps. It often makes one look like you are wearing a loaded diaper on your wrist.
 
Posts
13,154
Likes
52,275
I think the NATO strap is the problem - a leather or rubber strap might be better
+1
 
Posts
12
Likes
35
Is the warranty period allowing to return it for this reason though?

I found out that something that bothered me on a watch rarely goes away - changing straps can help, but just a bit.

If you wear smaller watches frequently, then you might always be surprised by the size when you pick it up.

If it bothers you, then I would seek to exchange it. After all it needs to feel right to get some wrist time.
Yep these are my other two. I just got the constellation but have had the 36 date just for a bit. Still debating on changing straps to a rubber, I can return for any reason (Amazon) and I have until sep 20th.
 
Posts
6,541
Likes
26,513
My first thought is, are you wearing the nato correctly? The buckle is in a naturally high position and literally protrudes off the lugs, which will visually and physically make the watch seem bigger than it is.

 
Posts
219
Likes
208
I have to agree with the strap comments. The way you have it now makes the watch look bigger than it is. Maybe adjust or change the strap and try again to see how you feel about it. Ultimately, what matters is that you like the watch and feel comfortable with it, so don't get too hung up on our opinions.

I suffered the reverse effect some months ago. Used to wear medium to big watches, it surprised me how tiny a vintage Omega or a Seiko Presage that I had just gotten looked on my wrist. It kinda put me off at the beginning but I adapted quickly.