Unpolished cases.

Posts
2,520
Likes
17,831
You guys all recognize that there’s something a little perverse with this thread?

Don’t misunderstand, I’m appreciating the photos and I can see the value. I’m glad you’re all contributing.

But this is sort of deep end stuff. I might be embarrassed to have some one looking over my shoulder.

“You’re looking at WHAT?”
 
Posts
1,648
Likes
6,714
Unless the scratches are deep, the amount of material removed would be imperceptible to the naked eye, and likely even very difficult to determine with taking measurements (there would be less material removed than the initial manufacturing variances).

If done properly, on a watch that is not badly beat up, you would not be able to tell.

Cheers, Al

Reassuring to hear from a professional that it is in fact possible to polish without removing facets or detail.
 
Posts
29,344
Likes
75,903
Reassuring to hear from a professional that it is in fact possible to polish without removing facets or detail.

That's why I consider claims of a watch being "unpolished" to be pretty much meaningless. Unless you have owned the watch since day 1, and never had it taken in for service, there's no way to be 100% certain that it's never been polished. And when I say never been polished I mean after it was originally polished, because of course it was polished when it was made...

It's a claim that can't really be proven, so for me much more prudent to simply describe the condition without using that term, and let the photos speak for themselves.
 
Posts
6,649
Likes
11,481
That's why I consider claims of a watch being "unpolished" to be pretty much meaningless. Unless you have owned the watch since day 1, and never had it taken in for service, there's no way to be 100% certain that it's never been polished. And when I say never been polished I mean after it was originally polished, because of course it was polished when it was made...

It's a claim that can't really be proven, so for me much more prudent to simply describe the condition without using that term, and let the photos speak for themselves.

Perhaps an exception to this can be made - if the watch is gold plated or gold capped?
 
Posts
29,344
Likes
75,903
Perhaps an exception to this can be made - if the watch is gold plated or gold capped?

It would depend on the thickness of the gold I suppose. Gold capped I have refinished myself, so know it can be done. Gold plating can be reapplied, but depending on the quality of the work may be easily spotted.
 
Posts
6,649
Likes
11,481
Gold cap can look nice unpolished also:

4326210356_3f9f6c9d93_z.jpg

8557496657_f080e89774_z.jpg
 
Posts
2,266
Likes
4,262
My favourite thread ever! 😀

Goose bumps

Whatabout an unpolished 1655, how common are they??

 
Posts
3,537
Likes
7,567
Details of a NOS 30 T2 Rg chronometer ref 2366



you can see the patina which evolved over the decades