Thoughts on this CALATRAVA?

Posts

166

Likes

291

ACC1965

·Jul 24, 2024

Good evening/afternoon/morning,

I saw this watch and was wondering what the community's thoughts were.
I could not find this dial on a reference and wonder if it is authentic.
The site says:

PATEK PHILIPPE, REF. 1578 18K YELLOW GOLD 'CALATRAVA' WATCH

Maker: Patek Philippe
Model: Calatrava
Reference number: 1578
Serial number: 6761XX
Year: Circa 1950s
Case size: Approx. 35 mm
Case material: 18K yellow gold
Dial: Champagne
Movement: Caliber 27 SC manual wind
Bracelet/Strap: Brown leather
Stamps: Inner case back: 0750 REF 1578 6761XX (Swiss hallmarks). Movement: 702123. Case back: (Swiss hallmark).

 

Posts

5,351

Likes

9,117

BlackTalon

·Jul 24, 2024·This Space for Rent

Can you get higher resolution photos?

 

Posts

29,332

Likes

35,324

dsio

·Jul 24, 2024·Ash @ ΩF

Half the people opening this are checking to see what watch you’re calling a calatrava but in this case it’s actually a calatrava lol

 

Posts

166

Likes

291

ACC1965

·Jul 24, 2024

dsio

Half the people opening this are checking to see what watch you’re calling a calatrava but in this case it’s actually a calatrava lol

I may not be smart, but I know what a Calatrava is.

 

Posts

166

Likes

291

ACC1965

·Jul 24, 2024

BlackTalon

Can you get higher resolution photos?

Unfortunately not. If I buy it I can post more, but until then this is all I’m working with :/

 

Posts

29,332

Likes

35,324

dsio

·Jul 24, 2024·Ash @ ΩF

ACC1965

I may not be smart, but I know what a Calatrava is.

Na it’s just that so many people talk about Omega dress watches as calatravas, Longines models etc to the point that it’s super commonly misused but you were entirely correct

 

Posts

62

Likes

64

lightweight

·Jul 26, 2024

Maybe fire off a request to John Reardon at Collectability? There is no guarantee that he will help as he is also in the business of selling these watches. Worth a shot though.

I am curious about where you are buying this watch from and why you are keen to part with Patek money when you don't trust the seller to recognize or disclose a redial.

The first adage of vintage watch buying applies here "buy the seller not the watch!".

He always struck me as a kind and helpful sort though.

 

Posts

179

Likes

152

asloper6001

·Aug 12, 2024

Hodinkee just did a video/podcast on most of all the Calatrava models for Patek with Ben. Might be worth listening too.

 

Posts

1,883

Likes

1,552

Drawarms

·Aug 31, 2024

IMO - I would er on the side of a redial here and not worth purchasing.