Speedmaster Mark II overpolished case

Posts
29
Likes
26
I wanted to post a picture of a Mark II that looks to be polished to death. After doing some preliminary research, this may be the most important shot to asses a Mark II case history. This is an obvious no go in my book.

 
Posts
2,006
Likes
3,382
Maybe it’s the facetless version? 😲

Honestly, I’d rather have clear facets with scratches than it be rounded off like this. I’m constantly seeings ads for watches that start with the word ‘Polished’ like that’s a good thing. Give it a sympathetic clean, sure, but don’t buff it to death. It reminds me of the silver items on Antiques Roadshow where they’ve been over-polished so that the hallmarks can’t be read, devaluing the item.
 
Posts
29
Likes
26
Maybe it’s the facetless version? 😲

Honestly, I’d rather have clear facets with scratches than it be rounded off like this. I’m constantly seeings ads for watches that start with the word ‘Polished’ like that’s a good thing. Give it a sympathetic clean, sure, but don’t buff it to death. It reminds me of the silver items on Antiques Roadshow where they’ve been over-polished so that the hallmarks can’t be read, devaluing the item.

I agree. Would much rather have an untouched case than one with no lines/edges. The watch in first pic in this thread was looks like it was polished many times.
 
Posts
29
Likes
26
Guess you didn't buy it then, huh? 😁
I passed on the one we were discussing. Came to the conclusion that it wasn't worth the risk without seeing a movement picture. 🙄