Sizes??? You really gotta try before you buy....

Posts
1,615
Likes
3,862
Well, how topical. As @JwRosenthal can attest (sorry to have dragged you into the size miasma!), case size has been quite the issue for me of late. After humming and hawing over some 34mm Air Kings and Tudor Oyster Princes and the like over the last while, I was ready to pull the trigger. Went down to a local shop yesterday to try on a lovely Tudor Oyster Royal. A damn good thing, too; even the watchmaker had to admit it looked a bit small.

Now, I'm not a large fellow by any stretch (5'10/160lbs), but it appears 40 years of playing drums + regular weight training has had an effect on my wrists - they're just under 7.5". This limits my true enjoyment of some truly stunning pieces; like a scratch or blemish on the dial, I'd have a hard time enjoying something that didn't feel just right. My 2254 and Speedmaster fit me perfectly. I like the weight and they sit nicely. This isn't to say I don't love my 34-36 vintage pieces; they're all dial and have long lugs (always been a leg, er, lug man) so they wear a bit bigger.

Short story even longer...absolutely try it on first.

Bracelet, or leather strap?

Because I had a Tudor oyster 7965 two or three years ago on leather, I sold it because it felt small. I bought another one recently, black dial and steel bracelet, I'll just keep it probably. Feels bigger on a bracelet, I have the same wrist size than you.

 
Posts
5,631
Likes
5,812
Good point you make, the strap or bracelet makes a large difference in how large a watch might appear.
 
Posts
897
Likes
2,822
I overlooked it because it was a cool-ass watch. I can’t do it anymore.

Im guilty of this. I can’t say my Seamaster 300 is a perfect fit but I just love the watch too damn much to care.
 
Posts
6,609
Likes
26,750
On a 7” wrist, I have found my sweet spot to be 39mm but have an absolute favorite down at 33mm. 42mm, when the proportions are right, feels good but 42mm is tops for me.

If wrist shots are anything, they are misleading as they don’t give a true representation of size.
From largest to smallest
43mm and almost 52mm lug to lug



42mm 145.0022 ‘85


40mm, this Sub is incredibly comfy with its proportions


My sweet spot at 39mm


37mm


34mm (wears a lot better on its rivet bracelet)


33mm and one of my favorite pieces

Edited: